Bryce Gibbs & Marc Murphy

[kruddler]

I've been arguing this for months but the Murphy and Gibbs haters refuse to accept the truth about our list! I'm sure they'd rather keep the spuds and get rid of the leaders, before eventually finding somebody else to blame like SOS or Bolton!

I'm certainly not a hater of either, but that being said, i'm all for trading them.

I understand you need to improve the list, rather than trade like for like and get nowhere. However, my reasoning for doing so is that in a few years, we might not have them around at all, nor will we have any talent to replace them.

Trading an a-grader who is approaching 30, for an a-grader who is in his early 20's entering his prime IS improving the list as it means we have an a-grader on our list for another say 7 years thanks to the trade.

Look at it this way.
We traded Fev away late in his career.
That got us Henderson.
We traded Henderson away
That got us a 1st round pick.
That was part of the GWS trade but basically got us pick 8.
Pick 8, was eventually pick 10 which got us Harry McKay

So traded away an old Fevola got us a 10year+ Harry McKay.

What might we get for Gibbs and/or Murphy?