07-16-2017, 11:50 PM
(07-16-2017, 11:14 PM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Interesting that whilst many have bagged Graham (and even Gibbs) other gave both decent votes in the Jim Park?They were both pretty clearly in the top 5-7 players by any measure. Graham wasn't too bad, had it 23 times and kicked a goal + 2 goal assists. Made a few errors, but wasn't alone in that. With Cripps and Curnow missing he did ok, but like a few on here I don't think he is AFL quality as he doesn't have a major weapon.
Haven't seen the game yet, hopefully tonight.
Gibbs played a 'standard' Gibbs game - got good numbers but didn't really impact the game hugely. Bont on the other hand was exceptional for them.
It was a disappointing but not unexpected performance given the line up. Sumner, Boek and Buckley aren't good enough, even with the wide open spaces yesterday and their careers on the line. We keep putting out the same forward line, despite our constant inability to kick goals. Fisher and Jack couldn't hit the scoreboard, and Cas was his usual self - 12 possessions, 1 goal and a howler when the team needed him to kick a goal to go with his 1 tackle. He kills me that guy.
With 6 weeks to go I would play Pickett, H and Macreadie each game - these guys are at least going to be at the club next year.