Need to Stick fat.

[blue4life]

Are you saying Judd isn't worth what we paid / gave up for him ? IMO, he has delivered in spades and he's worth every cent. I would do the deal again in a heartbeat. You don't say no when arguably the greatest player of his generation wants to come to your club.

I'm saying that he came at a very high price and ultimately the club won't achieve success while he's a Carlton player, I'm not for a moment questioning his ability or commitment to the club.
We were miles off being a Premiership contender when we recruited Judd and one player was never going to make the difference no matter how good he was, we should have shown patience but it was as much about marketing and membership as it was about winning premierships.