2017 Round 4 : Post Game thread - Carlton V Gold Coast

[cookie2]

Polson, Sheehan, Jones (at least he can play a role).

Apparently Sheehan limped off during the NB game. I didn't see it myself but my mate said he didn't look good.

[shawny]

Polson, Sheehan, Jones (at least he can play a role).

Jones.......really  :o

[cimm1979]

Got back from the game and  there was a clear difference in the level of skill and pace between both teams....GC are probably the quickest team in the comp and after half time we didnt have the wheels to go with some of their players. Early we matched them, tackled hard and made the game a series of contests which suits our style but once we tired their pace and our poor kicking skills provided then with plenty of rebound opportunities and they hurt us on the rebound badly.
Didnt think their centre square setup did the damage it was their ball carriers off half back charging away and  creating the overlap and in the end they were just burning our blokes off..
Lynch got a lot of his marks through getting the initial break on his opponents and Rowe was a victim of that in the main...our man likes to push and shove but Lynch always had him losing front position and losing contact so his famous spoiling was a non event
Plowman and Marchbank were not big enough to play on either Lynch or Wright and with GC's quick ball movement it was always one on one contests which didnt allow for help defense...
Our midfield was down, Kruezer was ok without being great and apart from Docherty the defense struggled....up forward we were also poor, Casboult and Silvagni got some late junk time goals but I wasnt that impressed with their games.

Daisy was booed during the player intros, copped flak during the game from our supporters and even on the way home on the train the talk wasnt about Zac Fisher's goal or nice debut it was all about Daisy and what a waste of time he is....

Weitering down forward may need reviewing, played on May who looked unusually meek and mild but still struggled to get to contests....
Charlie Curnow..wasnt impressed apart from some good marks, lazy at picking up his man, not keen on too much running and when he does make the effort gets in the wrong places or is too late to the contest or offering a lead....either is too slow to pick up opponents or doesnt want to..

Fisher and Williamson give hope...both use the ball well and look at home playing seniors..Samo and Pickett have skill but not the composure yet...

Marchbank...great mark. nice kicking style but overcooks most kicks....and is a turnover merchant
Plowman...great defender but well beat tonight and his kicking was ordinary..

Port are similar to GC so I hope we have learned something and give a better account of ourselves next game....

How many games do you think they'll win this year EB?

This time last year people were talking about top 4 and they appear to be back to that level.

I think, at their best, they are just about as good as anyone but they're as flaky as shit.

PS, Abblett is a parasite on and off the field. King of the cheapie and completely selfish.

[PaulP]

How many games do you think they'll win this year EB?

This time last year people were talking about top 4 and they appear to be back to that level.

I think, at their best, they are just about as good as anyone but they're as flaky as crap.

PS, Abblett is a parasite on and off the field. King of the cheapie and completely selfish.

Back from the dead CIMM - been busy ?

[cimm1979]

Back from the dead CIMM - been busy ?

Could say that and I'm having a holiday of sorts ATM .????

[shawny]

Big picture guys - I was again pleased with what I saw. The kids are amazingly good considering our early into their career they are.

What do we expect to see? 

Had 9 players under 21 and went down by under 5 goals to a team who beat hawks by a record margin - all this the next week after playing in hard terrible condition that must have taxed our kids young bodies. How did essendon fare this week?

We had 8 kids in this match with the most experienced having 12 games to their name.  They all played in one game yet too many expect to see a stellar performance.

Think many need to lower their expectations - either your commited to the rebuild or your not. If your commited you have to be pleased with what your seeing.

I know I am.

[blue4life]

I can't understand the knocks on the little champ Ablett,  I get the tribal thing but not being able to see his sublime skills and the ability to turn a game and inspire his team mates is wilful blindness IMO.
He'd make a world of difference at Carlton even at this late stage of his career.
That said, I think we can expect another loss in Adelaide next weekend, but so long as the club keeps the faith with the young fellas I'm prepared to wear a few beatings. 

[cimm1979]

Big picture guys - I was again pleased with what I saw. The kids are amazingly good considering our early into their career they are.

What do we expect to see? 

Had 9 players under 21 and went down by under 5 goals to a team who beat hawks by a record margin - all this the next week after playing in hard terrible condition that must have taxed our kids young bodies. How did essendon fare this week?

We had 8 kids in this match with the most experienced having 12 games to their name.  They all played in one game yet too many expect to see a stellar performance.

Think many need to lower their expectations - either your commited to the rebuild or your not. If your commited you have to be pleased with what your seeing.

I know I am.

Could not be happier....well I suppose winning would be nice but this is the next best thing.

[cimm1979]

I can't understand the knocks on the little champ Ablett,  I get the tribal thing but not being able to see his sublime skills and the ability to turn a game and inspire his team mates is wilful blindness IMO.
He'd make a world of difference at Carlton even at this late stage of his career.
That said, I think we can expect another loss in Adelaide next weekend, but so long as the club keeps the faith with the young fellas I'm prepared to wear a few beatings.

Selfish, entitled player .

I'm glad the GC are holding him to his obligations and I hope they do again next year.

[Micky0]

I didn't hear Daisy booed when the players were introduced?  There was muted applause for him, sure, and that was absolutely fine, but no booing.

Yes there was a huge boo when he completely fucked up a 15m kick to our running advantage when we were trying to get some momentum back - i think it was the beginning of the 4th when we got a break.  It was well deserved imo - absolutely not good enough -and that was the 3rd time that had happened in the game, the first two the supporters did an exasperated sigh - very loud - the 3rd one yes he copped it.

I don't condone booing either - i was embarrassed they were booing Ablett too, it shows huge immaturity to boo a champion - remember people doing that to Judd?  Just embarrassing.  And I'd never do it to one of ours but ffs Daisy is done.  He should retire.

Apart from that, i am EXCITED about our future - very excited!  That first half was exhilarating footy that we have not played in a long time