Round 8 Preview - Carlton v Geelong

[Robblues]

Would rather have kept McClean than seen Ellard run out again, been there long enough to make a mark and he isn't. Not really a Graham fan, but has been treated badly, deserved a spot yesterday.

[blue4life]

Time for Ellard and Carrazzo to go.  Both are finished at senior level.

Graham and Boek/Buckley to come in as they had great games yesterday.  Smith had a good game but he is a rookie so we cant play him.

Smith was our fourth round pick in the draft, he's not a rookie.
I like what he's shown so far and thought he was stiff to be dropped this week, I think Buckley should be picked for the next month so we can make a decision on him.
This is his fourth season and he's either going to measure up or he isn't.

[MosquitoFleet]

Time for Ellard and Carrazzo to go.  Both are finished at senior level.

Graham and Boek/Buckley to come in as they had great games yesterday.  Smith had a good game but he is a rookie so we cant play him.

also 2E white watson as a minimum

[age]

Smith was our fourth round pick in the draft, he's not a rookie.
I like what he's shown so far and thought he was stiff to be dropped this week, I think Buckley should be picked for the next month so we can make a decision on him.
This is his fourth season and he's either going to measure up or he isn't.

Oops.  Meant Walsh not Smith  Anyway I reckon he needs to be given a go.  Can't do worse than Carrazzo/Ellard.

[Robblues]

Unless Hendo is back, would keep Watson, hard to see how anyone would have done much better in the role he had yesterday. Ball just never got there. If Hendo is not there who would you go with? There just aren't any KP players left? Jones seemed to start well , but , but then nothing again.

[ElwoodBlues1]

Unless Hendo is back, would keep Watson, hard to see how anyone would have done much better in the role he had yesterday. Ball just never got there. If Hendo is not there who would you go with? There just aren't any KP players left? Jones seemed to start well , but , but then nothing again.

Agree.. we cant drop Watson after one game and need to give him a couple more....this Geelong game could get ugly. hopefully Jamison is back...Rowe and Jaksch  wont cut it against either Clark and Hawkins.

[PassIt2Carrots]

Agree.. we cant drop Watson after one game and need to give him a couple more....this Geelong game could get ugly. hopefully Jamison is back...Rowe and Jaksch  wont cut it against either Clark and Hawkins.

If Mick is still coach Watson will be dropped, you can take it to the bank. Also if Mick is coach the Graham will be selected and start as sub. You can also take that one to the bank.

[bratblue]

I wish it wasn't on TV, its all too sad to watch. This mob has taken away hope.

[ElwoodBlues1]

If Mick is still coach Watson will be dropped, you can take it to the bank. Also if Mick is coach the Graham will be selected and start as sub. You can also take that one to the bank.

Maybe Graham is too much like Daisy and Mick can only love one son....

[shawny]

Agree.. we cant drop Watson after one game and need to give him a couple more....this Geelong game could get ugly. hopefully Jamison is back...Rowe and Jaksch  wont cut it against either Clark and Hawkins.

Watson has played 20 AFL games and had over 4 years in the system.

He has not improved one bit. The guy shows nothing. Absolutely nothing. Can't even do the basics.

Ellard Watson Armfield to name a few, all well and truly have had their time. Enough now.

We beat dead horses longer then any other team - to the point they have no trade value and have clogged the list for 2 years longer then they should.