Login

kruddler · 09-05-2024, 04:23 AM

(09-05-2024, 01:16 AM)Sub-Zero link Wrote:B: McGovern Weitering Cowan
HB: Saad Young Newman
C: Acres Cripps Binns
HF: E. Hollands McKay Cincotta
F: Owies Curnow Williams
R: de Koning Hewett Walsh
I: Docherty O. Hollands Kemp Kennedy
S: Cerra

You didn't follow the rules by including Docherty.

Sub-Zero · 09-05-2024, 04:59 AM

(09-05-2024, 04:23 AM)kruddler link Wrote:You didn't follow the rules by including Docherty.

But things have changed. The prognosis of Docherty being out for the year has changed. The news is, he will play on Saturday. Others have also voted Fogarty and Cottrell. They've also been ruled out for the rest of the year.
Boyd instead of Docherty, if that's the case.

kruddler · 09-05-2024, 05:07 AM

(09-05-2024, 04:59 AM)Sub-Zero link Wrote:But things have changed. The prognosis of Docherty being out for the year has changed. The news is, he will play on Saturday. Others have also voted Fogarty and Cottrell. They've also been ruled out for the rest of the year.
Boyd instead of Docherty, if that's the case.

Its not about picking the side thats playing this week.
Its about picking a side based on the players that are deemed eligible.
Its all in the first post.

Reason being, i want to get some consistency throughout the course of the year by choosing from the same set of players. If we only choose who is fit at the time, that doesn't tell us which players are best, but rather the best of whats available.
To keep things consistent, Docherty has been out all year, so will not be in any other teams. So for consistency, keep him out of this selection as well.

Login
Username:
Password:	Lost Password?
	Remember me

Poll: Who is in our best 22? You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
1 - Jack Silvagni ineligible, out for year	0%	0	0%
2 - Lachie Cowan	2.81%	8	2.81%
3 - Jesse Motlop	0.70%	2	0.70%
4 - Oliver Hollands	4.56%	13	4.56%
5 - Adam Cerra	3.16%	9	3.16%
6 - Zac Williams	4.21%	12	4.21%
7 - Matt Kennedy	4.21%	12	4.21%
8 - Lachie Fogarty	1.75%	5	1.75%
9 - Patrick Cripps	4.56%	13	4.56%
10 - Harry McKay	4.56%	13	4.56%
11 - Mitch McGovern	4.21%	12	4.21%
12 - Tom De Koning	4.56%	13	4.56%
13 - Blake Acres	4.56%	13	4.56%
14 - Orazio Fantasia	0.70%	2	0.70%
15 - Sam Docherty ineligible, out for year	0.35%	1	0.35%
16 - Jack Carroll	0.70%	2	0.70%
17 - Brodie Kemp	4.21%	12	4.21%
18 - Sam Walsh	4.56%	13	4.56%
19 - Corey Durdin	0%	0	0%
20 - Elijah Hollands	4.56%	13	4.56%
21 - Jack Martin	1.05%	3	1.05%
22 - Caleb Marchbank	0%	0	0%
23 - Jacob Weitering	4.56%	13	4.56%
24 - Nick Newman	4.56%	13	4.56%
25 - Jaxon Binns	0.70%	2	0.70%
27 - Marc Pittonet	1.40%	4	1.40%
28 - David Cuningham	0%	0	0%
29 - George Hewett	4.56%	13	4.56%
30 - Charlie Curnow	4.56%	13	4.56%
31 - Harry Lemmey	0%	0	0%
32 - Matt Carroll	0%	0	0%
33 - Lewis Young	1.05%	3	1.05%
34 - Rob Monahan	0%	0	0%
35 - Billy Wilson	0%	0	0%
37 - Jordan Boyd	2.46%	7	2.46%
38 - Sam Durdin	0%	0	0%
39 - Alex Cincotta	4.56%	13	4.56%
40 - Hudson O'Keeffe	0%	0	0%
41 - Dom Akuei	0%	0	0%
42 - Adam Saad	4.21%	12	4.21%
43 - Ashton Moir	1.75%	5	1.75%
44 - Matt Owies	3.86%	11	3.86%
45 - Alex Mirkov	0%	0	0%
46 - Matt Cottrell	1.05%	3	1.05%
*36 - Cooper Lord - MSD pickup	0.70%	2	0.70%
Total		285 vote(s)	100%