AFL Rd 13 2024 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Essendon

[PaulP]

For Essendon, Redman is out, and Goldstein, Shiel, Setterfield, Roberts in.

[madbluboy]

Fantasia is out following an injury in the Port game

https://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/157234...7m5KaEb9RQ

It did say sub injured live on the AFL app last week but I thought it was a mistake.

[PaulP]

Just the one ruckman.

Is Pittonet still injured, or was he declared fit and omitted ? The former seems more likely ?

[DJC]

Good inclusions

Not if you're going on their form in the VFL.  They were all poor to average and don't deserve a senior game if the way they played in the VFL is important.

[DJC]

Is Pittonet still injured, or was he declared fit and omitted ? The former seems more likely ?

He was a test but could have passed and been overlooked.

I suspect that he would have been named on the bench if fit.

[PaulP]

He was a test but could have passed and been overlooked.

I suspect that he would have been named on the bench if fit.

That seems reasonable.

[madbluboy]

We have the bye next week so that hives his finger another 2 weeks.

[PaulP]

Not if you're going on their form in the VFL.  They were all poor to average and don't deserve a senior game if the way they played in the VFL is important.

I had this thought as well. I hope the MC knows what they're doing.

[tex]

I had this thought as well. I hope the MC knows what they're doing.

2 goals Motlop lock it in

[DJC]

2 goals Motlop lock it in

Hold you to that Tex!