AFL Rd 12 2023 Pre Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne

[pinot]

Dow has to be selected this week - never seen a player knock (bash) down the door like Paddy Dow.

[townsendcalling]

Time to get creative and throw the magnets around

Out: Cripps, Newman, Holland, Hewett, Kennedy (inj) Cerra (susp) McGovern (omitted, shirks too many contests)
In Cincotta, Young, Dow, Fisher, Silvagni, Marcbank, Binns.

Cincotta      Weitering    Kemp
Saad            Young          Boyd
Acres          Dow            Doherty
Owies          De Koning  Fisher
Durdin        McKay        Silvagni

Pittonet    C. Curow    Walsh

Inter:  Motlop, Marchbank, Binns Cottrell          Sub  Fogarty

[Gointocarlton]

Oliver looks like a chance to get up for Melbourne too which isnt good news for us.....

Goodwin was just on SEN and defintitely ruled him out for this week, will return the following week.

[pinot]

What about leaving Cripps as a permanent forward and taking him out of the middle and only rotate through there.

That would be my first go-to move. Crippa and Charlie could be a good combination

Not sure what to do with H

[pinot]

F: Owies  Charlie  TDK
HF: Motlop  Crippa  Fisher

[Three Votes]

What about leaving Cripps as a permanent forward and taking him out of the middle and only rotate through there.

Applaud you for the lateral thinking, but the Skipper is a worse set-shot for goal than Chris Judd was!  :

[pinot]

Applaud you for the lateral thinking, but the Skipper is a worse set-shot for goal than Chris Judd was!  :

True but couldnt be worse than Harry.

[Adelaideblue]

What about leaving Cripps as a permanent forward and taking him out of the middle and only rotate through there.

That would be my first go-to move. Crippa and Charlie could be a good combination

Not sure what to do with H

Yes good to move both Harry & Crippa in games when getting monstered  As said in an earlier post, Harry could be a sensation at Centre Half Back
Ab

[kruddler]

True but couldnt be worse than Harry.

You sure about that?

Crupps was 1.9 this year I think?

Fwiw, I've suggested similar.
Have Kennedy as a forward who swaps with cripps through the middle.

That way we get the one who can kick goals playing forward most.

[laj]

Yes good to move both Harry & Crippa in games when getting monstered  As said in an earlier post, Harry could be a sensation at Centre Half Back
Ab

Give Harry a run in the ruck like Brisbane does with Daniher. Nothing like running around the ground taking marks to help your confidence.