Pre Game Promise AFL Rd20: Carlton vs St. Kilda

[ElwoodBlues1]

Charlie was basically told he wouldn't be in for Ed 200th but should be in for the next week...which is this game.

Kemp has had enough hitouts now that he should be given a crack at it.

Obviously Harry is an automatic.

I also think its time to give Honey and/or Ramsay a crack. Both have been in the emergencies at various stages this year and deserve their shot.

As mentioned, there will be a few forced outs - Williams and IMO Betts will make 2.
I have seen nothing from Cottrell for a month or more now that makes me think he deserves a spot in the side.
Williamson might be offering a smidge more, but not deserving either. Let Kemp try his role.
Murphy had no influence on the game and should be limped to 300 via the medical sub at most.

I don't think i'm asking much.

Williamson had a shocker, think he had Thomas and also may have had some time on Stephenson... be Kemp in for me.

[kruddler]

Williamson had a shocker, think he had Thomas and also may have had some time on Stephenson...

I think he's been lucky to keep his spot for weeks, but he may as well of had a North jumper on yesterday, he couldn't have hurt us anymore if he did.

[ElwoodBlues1]

I think he's been lucky to keep his spot for weeks, but he may as well of had a North jumper on yesterday, he couldn't have hurt us anymore if he did.

Yep, going to struggle to stay on the list, ditto for Cottrell..
Honey and Ramsay in cant be any worse.. Honey should have played more games imo...

[bmaurizio]

The Saints & Port games both are going to be really tough games, both need to cement a place for finals Saints perhaps a chance for the 8 and Port at home for top 4 spot so can’t see us getting close.
We should be a better chance against Suns , as for GWS another tough one, won’t be an easy game.

[PaulP]

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/blue...58d0f.html

[Gointocarlton]

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/blue...58d0f.html

Effin great, we can showcase our zero pressure high turnover game plan on the Friday night big stage.

[dodge]

So Betts and Williams out.  Players who are available to be selected who weren't in the team:

Who comes in?  Does anyone else go out?  Cupboard is bare.  I think the result will be a bit grim.  But it is the coaches fault.

LOB
Fogarty
McKay (doubtful)
McGovern
Carroll
Kemp
Parks
Durdin
Curnow C
Ramsay
Honey

[tonyo]

We struggle to beat this mob even when we are going well.  No hope......

[Slowhand]

We now hand 17 on the injured list.

MERCY RULE PLEASE….

[WASurfer]

Prime time Friday night slot! I can hear the howls of derision now from others about how we stunk it up.....again.