Pre Game Postulations: AFL 2020 Rd 17: Carlton vs Adelaide

[capcom]

I'd take him back.

1 year deal.

He's getting a (at least partial) payout from ADL for 2021.  Still a firm no from me.

[Baggers]

I find it pretty easy. 

His game against the Bombers shows what he can do.    Only managed to piece together 36 games.

We need bloke that can run and carry.  That's Cunningham.

Not sure we can carry a bloke who plays one good game in 36.    ;D

[Shakin77]

Not sure we can carry a bloke who plays one good game in 36.    ;D

Carried plenty of others. 

[flyboy77]

He's getting a (at least partial) payout from ADL for 2021.  Still a firm no from me.

He'd obviously need to show he still wanted to play.....

But if we were in a final in 2020 with minutes to play who would you prefer delivering the ball to inside 50?

Gibbs, Dow, Cottrell, O'Brien......

Quite frankly (and again presuming he still has the desire), I'd prefer him on our list in 2021 than Simmo.

Let's be honest, he was an easy whipping boy at the Crows as soon as that camp fiasco stuff dragged on and needed a scapegoat for their poor onfield efforts.

[LP]

Big test for De Koning this week, O'Brien is in red hot ruck form at the moment, quite mobile and hard at the contest.

I think De Koning can hurt them by pushing hard into F50 and having O'Brien follow.

[capcom]

He'd obviously need to show he still wanted to play.....

But if we were in a final in 2020 with minutes to play who would you prefer delivering the ball to inside 50?

Gibbs, Dow, Cottrell, O'Brien......

Quite frankly (and again presuming he still has the desire), I'd prefer him on our list in 2021 than Simmo.

Let's be honest, he was an easy whipping boy at the Crows as soon as that camp fiasco stuff dragged on and needed a scapegoat for their poor onfield efforts.

Still a thumbs down ... contract = (mandated) money.  In any event, reckon he's settled in ADL

[Baggers]

Carried plenty of others. 

And it's time it stopped. Time to set the bar and tolerance much higher.

[laj]

And it's time it stopped. Time to set the bar and tolerance much higher.

Plus lists are reduced next year anyway.

[ElwoodBlues1]

Carried plenty of others. 

Still do, we should be sponsored by Linfox..

[flyboy77]

https://www.afc.com.au/news/811069

No Talia.

Talls down back for them Hartigan @194cm and 1 game rookie Butts at 198cm.