2018 Jim Park Voting: Rd 16: Carlton vs St Kilda

[Baggers]

Team F-

6 - Cripps

3 - Curnow C

3 - Fisher

1 - Dow

1 - Lamb

1 - Thomas

HM: Curnow E.

[flyboy77]

This is Murphy all over sadly.

He did try, but he was not overly influential.

[ElwoodBlues1]

Sam Rowe:  Wasn’t embarrassed, but was not that great either.....played on Marshall and Membrey at times and was well stitched up IMO...was too soft on both and looks shot as a player IMO.I'd mention his kicking but I like Sam and wouldnt want to embarrass him...

[cookie2]

Sam Rowe:  Wasn’t embarrassed, but was not that great either.....played on Marshall and Membrey at times and was well stitched up IMO...was too soft on both and looks shot as a player IMO.I'd mention his kicking but I like Sam and wouldnt want to embarrass him...

Agree. Sam has started to look like he is passing if he has not quite passed his use-by date.

[Jofo]

Team G-

7 - Cripps

5-  Fisher

2 - C Curnow

1 - Dow



1 - Thomas

[blue4life]

Team: Fail

5 Cripps
3 Fisher
3 C Curnow
2 Dow
1 McKay
1 Jones

[Blue Moon]

Team F
5. Cripps
4. Fisher
3. Dow
2. E Curnow
1. Jones

[DJC]

Team: F

5 - Cripps
4 - Curnow, E
3 - Fisher
2 - Curnow, C
1 - Murphy

[sandsmere]

Team. F

6. Cripps
3. Fisher
2. Ed Curnow
2. C Curnow
1. Thomas
1. Murphy

[crashlander]

I'll leave this thread open for tomorrow anyway. Not sure many others will want to vote, but ....