Post Game-Carlton v Collingwood

[ElwoodBlues1]

Or does Lobbe play against his old side? How will OShea fair against his old mob?

If OShea plays on anyone decent we will be carved up by about 10 goals.....was outbodied by the Pie kid Stephenson in the goal square and has zero nous for a bloke who has played 100 games..
Rather play Philips unless he is injured vs Ryder and Westhoff.....both are in a red hot form and Lobbe wont get near them around the ground....

[Professer E]

If Daisy goes so should a couple of Pies,  they threw a few sly ones today.

[ElwoodBlues1]

If Daisy goes so should a couple of Pies,  they threw a few sly ones today.

Maynard likes to throw jumper punches, bit too cocky that kid...Adams is a little pr..k...hope someone landed one on him...
Daisy did more pushing than punching....

[kruddler]

If OShea plays on anyone decent we will be carved up by about 10 goals.....was outbodied by the Pie kid Stephenson in the goal square and has zero nous for a bloke who has played 100 games..
Rather play Philips unless he is injured vs Ryder and Westhoff.....both are in a red hot form and Lobbe wont get near them around the ground....

OShea made 3 huge errors in the space of 2 minutes today.

2 kicks directly to an opponent, without a carlton bloke within cooee.
And then gave away a free kick in the goal square.

The bloke is a liability. I don't care how many injuries we have to our backs at present, he gives away more goals than he saves. Better off playing an extra mid in his place.

[kruddler]

Maynard likes throw jumper punches, bit too cocky that kid...Adams is a little pr..k...hope someone landed one on him...
Daisy did more pushing than punching....

Huddo reckoned someone gave Daisy a hook in the halftime melee today. Wasn't captured on camera from what i saw.

[Gointocarlton]

How can O'Shea play against Port, are they changing league to the VFL next week?

;D ;D

[Professer E]

What's your honest assessment of the game brother Elwood?

Ive just re-watched the first half and given the greatly undermanned side we fielded and some very questionable umpiring I thought the pies got out of gaol.  Either we are better than I thought or the pies are drinking their own bathwater a bit.  They didn't impress me one iota.

[ElwoodBlues1]

What's your honest assessment of the game brother Elwood?

Ive just re-watched the first half and given the greatly undermanned side we fielded and some very questionable umpiring I thought the pies got out of gaol.  Either we are better than I thought or the pies are drinking their own bathwater a bit.  They didn't impress me one iota.

Prof..reckon the bathwater is low in level at the luxus centre and most of it has found its way down their fat throats....overrated and they rely heavily on their midfield to get them out of trouble. If they lost Grundy and Pendlebury instead of us losing Kreuzer and Plowman the result would have been different.  They do one thing better than us and thats convert...Hoskin Elliott isnt a great player IMO and is as soft as butter but he does kick straight and the new kid Stephenson does similar. They probably have more depth as well and we have to bring in bananas like Oshea, Mullet etc and they can call on better quality back up...
I'd have them as midpack but their A grade midfield probably gets them in the finals but IMO they will be smashed by teams who can lock down on Treloar, Pendlebury, Sidebottom and crew.......
We played the extra man back today which also helped limit the damage, its probably going to have to stay that way till we get some more talent in.....

[Raydan]

If Daisy goes so should a couple of Pies,  they threw a few sly ones today.

Daisy will go for the sheperd that knocked out Gibson, off the field with concussion and it was shoulder to head.

[madbluboy]

Ryan Burton knocked out Shaun Higgins earlier in the year and got off.