2018 Jim Park Voting: Rd 2: Carlton vs Gold Coast

[flyboy77]

i couldn't give any votes today.

Yep, Ed and Cripps tried hard but both didn't excute basic skills when needed - on several occasions...

Charlie -  a few cameos.

The rest - more bad than good.

[ElwoodBlues1]

Team E:

4: Fisher, not great but ok and  when he gets the ball he does something with it.
3: E. Curnow(Lot of the ball, tackled well but as we all know he doesnt hurt teams when he gets the footy, but he did play 4 quarters)
3: SPS, worked hard, missed a few targets but did try all game.
2: C. Curnow, terrible supply but ran hard vs a big bad dude in May and kept on keeping on,
1: Murphy( Agree with Fly, disposal was horrific, kicks high as they were long and easily picked off but I gave him a vote for effort)
1: Garlett( worked hard in last part of the game and didnt give up so I gave him a vote for encouragement)
1: Cripps..heavily tagged, not great by his high standards but he gave effort...

[LoveNavy]

Team E

3 Ed
2 Crippa
2 Charlie
2 Garlett
2 Samo
1 Murphy 
1 Zac
1 Daisy
1 Jones

[madbluboy]

Murphy is such a polarizing player even Supercoach and Fantasy points disagree about his impact.

Fantasy Points: 114
Supercoach: 73

[sandsmere]

Team. E

6. Ed Curnow
2. Cripps
2. Murphy
2. C. Curnow
2. Fisher
1. Petrevski-Seaton

[RiverRat]

Team = E


[4]  Patrick Cripps
[3]  Marc Murphy
[2]  Charlie Curnow
[2]  Sam Petrevski-Seton
[2]  Ed Curnow
[2]  Zac Fisher

[madbluboy]

F

8 Cripps
5 Charlie Curnow
2 Fisher

[shawny]

Team F

Ed 5
Fisher 4
Charlie 3
Cripps 3

[Baggers]

Team F

2 - Cripps

2 - Curnow C

2 - Curnow E

2 - SPS

1 - Fisher

1 - Jones

1 - Mullett

1 - Murphy

1 - Simpson

1 - Thomas

1 - Wright

HM: Garlett

[kruddler]

Staggers me how you give Murphy votes. His specialty has become soft sub 20m up and unders.

Sad fact is until we find a better Captain, we wont be much chop.

Staggers me how much you bag out our captain and one of our better players this season, yet think we are finals bound as a side and attack me (and others) for even suggesting a bottom 4 finish.