+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Lily Of Laguna (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: Ladies Lounge (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-19.html)
+--- Thread: AFLW 2020 - Votes (/thread-4609.html)
- kruddler - 12-26-2025
Test
AFLW 2020 - Votes - kruddler - 02-07-2020
To refresh peoples memory, the voting for the girls is different to that of the guys.
We use the traditional 3, 2, 1 method for votes (no splitting!)
So in a dominant win against the (other) 'old' enemy in R1, who deserves the 3, 2, 1?
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - DJC - 02-07-2020
It’s hard to pick three when so many played well and had significant influence on our performance. I’m still pondering ?
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - LP - 02-07-2020
3 - McEvoy
2 - Presparkis
1 - Loynes
I thought McEvoy played 4 quarters, which is why I have her ahead of Presparkis. For a first game McEvoy has already proven herself to be a significant recruit, and she'll get better when she used to playing in front of a crowd and at the AFLW speed. Seems to always have time and space when she gets the football, a bit like the Hyphen or Diesel!
Presparkis is very impressive when she gets on a role, but some of that came courtesy of the Nthmond coach releasing the tag, I thought she was well held early in the game when she got plenty of football but wasn't able to break away and do anything with it.
Loynes is a Selwood type, she does the unfashionable hard things at the right moment and keeps the team focused. Every team needs one of these type players, I suppose we are lucky as we have Loynes and the twins.
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - crashlander - 02-08-2020
(02-07-2020, 10:08 PM)DJC link Wrote:It’s hard to pick three when so many played well and had significant influence on our performance. I’m still pondering ?I agree with this totally. Basically every one of our girls did something and nobody really lowered their colours. However, it was such a even display that giving votes is very difficult:
[3] Maddy P: her disposal and her willing to get the first possession was excellent. And didn't the girls like it when she slotted that goal. 21 disposals , 7 more than anyone else, tells a real tale.
[2] Bree Moody: this was one of Moody's most effective game for us. She was excellent. her clearances from the middle were tha sort of thing that could win us matches.
[1] Tayla Harris: Dominated her position all night and provided a great target.
Honourable mentions:
Katie Loynes: a typical Loynes game. She is hard at the ball, took a couple of clutch marks and book the goal we really needed.
Lucy McEvoy: a really solid game for a first gamer. Her time was good, her skills were good and she looked very comfortable.
Sarah Hosking: an excellent game and deserving of a lot more mentions that I have written so far.
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - Jack Burton - 02-08-2020
3 Prespakis
2 McEvoy
1 Harris
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - kruddler - 02-08-2020
3. Prespakis
2. Moody
1. Harris
Apologies
Gee
Downie
McEvoy
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - RiverRat - 02-08-2020
3. Prespakis
2. Loynes
1. McEvoy
HM. Dalton, Harris
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - LoveNavy - 02-08-2020
3 Prespakis
2 Moody
1 Gee
So many solid contributors.
Congratulations girls
Re: AFLW 2020 - Votes - R1 vs Richmond - crashlander - 02-08-2020
I find it hard enough to spread 15 votes around, acknowledging those who deserve a mention. Having to go '3, 2, 1' is very hard indeed. And in an even performance all the more so.
In my (rather original) opinion, I thought that young Georgia Gee played probably her more effect game for us. he pace, run and good disposal was pleasing, even though she did get caught badly twice and kicked to bad intercepts. I am very pleased with her progress.