+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Around The Grounds (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-7.html)
+--- Forum: The Sports Desk (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-27.html)
+--- Thread: One day squad..No Maxwell???? (/thread-3583.html)
One day squad..No Maxwell???? - ElwoodBlues1 - 01-03-2018
The Aus selectors have confirmed Glen Maxwell is on the outer not through poor form on the field but poor form in the dressing room by leaving him out of the ODI squad.
They have to be kidding?..Chris Lynn is in but cant field properly due to injury, Maxwell is probably the best fielder in the country and has been in ok form in the Big Bash.
Steve Smith has said Maxwell has to train smarter....???........ok Smith and the inner circle dont like him but that doesnt mean he gets left out when his form warrants selection and then give a BS random excuse saying he has to train smarter....
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - DJC - 01-03-2018
An inexplicable decision ????
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - sandsmere - 01-03-2018
It is indeed a strange decision.
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - JonHenry - 01-03-2018
(01-03-2018, 07:35 PM)DJC link Wrote:An inexplicable decision ????
Maybe it's a team game and he doesn't want to do what he's told?
Let's face it, it ain't the first time he's had a kick in the bum.
At 29 you would think he would have pulled his head in
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - flyboy77 - 01-03-2018
(01-03-2018, 07:35 PM)DJC link Wrote:An inexplicable decision ????
Far from inexplicable clearly. That we don't know the reason (exactly) doesn't make it inexplicable!
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - Jack Burton - 01-03-2018
Same problem as Peter Handscomb, Brad Hodge, Dean Jones etc etc. If you choose to play for Victoria you limit your chances of playing for Australia
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - crashlander - 01-03-2018
There has to be more to this one than meets the eye of someone like me. Maxwell appears to be doing more of the right thing and certainly has runs on the board this year.
As for Chris Lynn, he was selected on last year's form as much as anything. He has been OK in the big bash, but his fielding is not up to standard. I understand why his fielding is ordinary, but it does look a little strange.
I don't know what Maxwell can do to get back in the good books when form with the bat is not the main criterion. Very interesting to see how he takes it.
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - ElwoodBlues1 - 01-03-2018
(01-03-2018, 09:12 PM)JonHenry link Wrote:Maybe it's a team game and he doesn't want to do what he's told?
Let's face it, it ain't the first time he's had a kick in the bum.
At 29 you would think he would have pulled his head in
Take your point about him being a lone wolf but I think its team Smith with Warner and crew not liking him, we had that incident with Wade when he was the incumbent keeper batting himself above Maxwell in the state game and Maxwell let everyone know he wasnt happy and Smith came out in support of Wade.
He isnt popular IMO but that shouldnt affect selection..Bradman didnt get on with OReilly, Fingleton etc but that didnt affect picking the best team.....Maxwell is one of the best one day cricketers in the country but isnt playing because Smith and crew dont like him IMO and thats wrong....
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - JonHenry - 01-03-2018
(01-03-2018, 11:35 PM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:Take your point about him being a lone wolf but I think its team Smith with Warner and crew not liking him, we had that incident with Wade when he was the incumbent keeper batting himself above Maxwell in the state game and Maxwell let everyone know he wasnt happy and Smith came out in support of Wade.
He isnt popular IMO but that shouldnt affect selection..Bradman didnt get on with OReilly, Fingleton etc but that didnt affect picking the best team.....Maxwell is one of the best one day cricketers in the country but isnt playing because Smith and crew dont like him IMO and thats wrong....
Agree, potentially he is one of the best one day players, but we have a World Cup coming up and Australia need performance not potential.
He obviously has been asked to work on aspects of his game, and he hasn't or won't.
Team Smith and Warner are captain and vice captain and if maxwell thinks he is going to pull the strings he's kidding himself
Re: One day squad..No Maxwell???? - DJC - 01-04-2018
(01-03-2018, 09:55 PM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Far from inexplicable clearly. That we don't know the reason (exactly) doesn't make it inexplicable!
Inexplicable = unable to be explained or accounted for. I'd like to hear the selectors account for Maxwell's omission. They may be able make something up but I don't believe they could provide a logical, defensible argument.
I wonder if they could do better than Smith's lame attempt at 'training smarter'. I don't think 'because he's a Victorian' will work.