+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Social Club (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-6.html)
+--- Forum: Blah-Blah Bar (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-23.html)
+--- Thread: NRL FS vs AFL FS (/thread-2345.html)
Pages:
1
2
NRL FS vs AFL FS - townsendcalling - 10-01-2015
The NRL world is generally seen as sexist, blokey and a boy's club, yet the NRL Footy Show is able to include a 'football intelligent' attractive female in Erin Molan who is shown a high degree of respect by both the panel and audience and not treated as a token female.
With the recent accusations leveled at Newman and Brownless and the deplorable history that the show has in dealing with women ( Newman's comments to those female footballers a few weeks ago was a disgrace) and the fact that the AFL footy show needs a revamp (desperately), are there any suggestions as to any females who might be able take their place legitimately as a panel member, to give the show some form of credibility??
My suggestion: Rebecca Maddern (ch 7) Heard her on SEN recently and was amazed at her football knowledge. I think she's the No 1 ticket holder at Geelong.
We can justifiably criticize the NRL on some issues but when comparing the two shows, the NRL are a mile ahead.
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - madbluboy - 10-01-2015
Daisy Pearce who spoke on Brownlow night was impressive.
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - LP - 10-02-2015
If you remember Bec Judd's answer to that patronising questioning she received on Brownlow night a few years ago, then I think you would realise she knows more about football than many footballers!
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - ItsOurTime - 10-02-2015
Didn't even realise this show was still going!
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - laj - 10-02-2015
(10-02-2015, 12:10 AM)ItsOurTime link Wrote:Didn't even realise this show was still going!
Yes, 22 years. It's closing in on an all time long running shows. Think Hey Hey It's Saturday went 28.
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - townsendcalling - 03-29-2016
(10-01-2015, 02:42 PM)townsendcalling link Wrote:The NRL world is generally seen as sexist, blokey and a boy's club, yet the NRL Footy Show is able to include a 'football intelligent' attractive female in Erin Molan who is shown a high degree of respect by both the panel and audience and not treated as a token female.
With the recent accusations leveled at Newman and Brownless and the deplorable history that the show has in dealing with women ( Newman's comments to those female footballers a few weeks ago was a disgrace) and the fact that the AFL footy show needs a revamp (desperately), are there any suggestions as to any females who might be able take their place legitimately as a panel member, to give the show some form of credibility??
My suggestion: Rebecca Maddern (ch 7) Heard her on SEN recently and was amazed at her football knowledge. I think she's the No 1 ticket holder at Geelong.
We can justifiably criticize the NRL on some issues but when comparing the two shows, the NRL are a mile ahead.
Happy to claim this one!!!!
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - Juddkreuzer - 03-29-2016
(03-29-2016, 09:04 AM)townsendcalling link Wrote:Happy to claim this one!!!!
Good get!!
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - DJC - 03-29-2016
(03-29-2016, 09:04 AM)townsendcalling link Wrote:Happy to claim this one!!!!
Nice prediction!
Now, if they replaced Newman, Brayshaw and Brownless, changed the format, and brought back Trevor Marmalade I might even think about watching the show.
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - jeza - 03-29-2016
(03-29-2016, 10:22 AM)DJC link Wrote:Nice prediction!
Now, if they replaced Newman, Brayshaw and Brownless, changed the format, and brought back Trevor Marmalade I might even think about watching the show.
Totally agree. Triple M humour is so self interested and boring.
Re: NRL FS vs AFL FS - laj - 03-30-2016
(03-29-2016, 10:22 AM)DJC link Wrote:Nice prediction!
Now, if they replaced Newman, Brayshaw and Brownless, changed the format, and brought back Trevor Marmalade I might even think about watching the show.
Without Sam the show dies. He's the one that drives the show.