+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon (/thread-2772.html)
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - DJC - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 04:17 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:Dont shoot the messenger kiddies
http://www.carltonfc.com.au/player-profile/jack-silvagni
Perhaps the bloke who weighed Jack is the same bloke who measured Marc Murphy's height as 1.80m
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - pinot - 06-06-2016
I swear I saw both Jack and Crippa standing together and were same height. So that makes him minimum 193 as I had him taller. Or it was an optical illusion
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - Gointocarlton - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 06:28 AM)pinot link Wrote:I swear I saw both Jack and Crippa standing together and were same height. So that makes him minimum 193 as I had him taller. Or it was an optical illusionMate Crippa is every bit of 195cm. Cam Mooney interviewed him on the ground after the game on Sat and they are the same height. My mate actually commented that he thought Mooney was looking up slightly.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - crashlander - 06-06-2016
[img[http://i.imgur.com/4fZiAz2.png[/img]
Interesting reading.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - townsendcalling - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 03:40 AM)cimm1979 link Wrote:This is an even weaker argument for selecting him in the firsts.
Big, usually slower and incapable of the full game pressure you get at the top level.
I'm sure there's 16 year olds who are ready for the top level but there are 20 year olds who need more time.
He cant run out a game, where do we play him?
The club has got every one of these calls right so far so I'll leave it to the experts.
X2
There is NO HURRY, folks! Not sure if some of these people pushing for him have actually seen him in action. If not, do yourself a favour and have a look. He is developing very nicely and will be great for us. The kid will have more pressure than most when he takes the field, I'll leave it to those who have made all the right decisions so far this year. They are more informed than any of us!
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - mateinone - 06-06-2016
I don't think we will play him yet and I am okay with him going for 40-50 goals as a target in the VFL to be honest, however he would not be the first 18 year old to have a crack with both Darcy Moore and Joe Daniher having their first senior game halfway through their first year at the club.... However... Jack is 11 months younger than Moore was when recruited and 9 months younger than Joe.
I think if he plays, great we get to see him trot out for his first game, but the club won't care about that as much, they will play him when they feel he is ready and not a moment before that.
As for supporters wanting to see him, of course they will, they have been waiting (not so patiently) since 1997 for him to play a game.
I admit my hopes for him are high, I stated last draft that I thought he would end up being in the top few from this draft and on the small amount of exposed form, I will stick with that.
(11-24-2015, 10:56 AM)mateinone link Wrote:I really have a feeling about Jack, I just think he will smash it. Might take him a couple of years to get on the park consistently and hopefully we have patience because he is very young in draft age terms, only making this years draft by 2 weeks.
I think we can expect at least 2-3 years of development for Jack as he builds out his body to play more key position style football.
I cannot help but think he could end up being in the top 3-4 players of this draft when we look back in 5-10 years.
Welcome Jack, we've been expecting you...
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - laj - 06-06-2016
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/teams/carlton/jack-silvagni-excites-carlton-fans-with-bestonground-performance-in-vfl/news-story/a1d2fa28542f457702aaf38b1defa6b5
To me, like any other player, if he's killing it with the NBs he ready to be promoted.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - DJC - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 09:42 AM)laj link Wrote:http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/teams/carlton/jack-silvagni-excites-carlton-fans-with-bestonground-performance-in-vfl/news-story/a1d2fa28542f457702aaf38b1defa6b5
To me, like any other player, if he's killing it with the NBs he ready to be promoted.
I'm looking forward to watching him at Box Hill on Saturday. I'll be interested to see if he can run out the game.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - shadesy - 06-06-2016
I came in thinking Jack was a nice to have. Free hit, bring hope to fans, maybe never play.
He has played well Consistently every week at VFL level as basically a colts/under 18 player.
I want to see him kick 6-7 one week, and have no problem him not playing this year.
But he has already proved me wrong...
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - RiverRat - 06-06-2016
(06-05-2016, 06:48 AM)Robblues link Wrote:Any one at the game? Has is SOSOS shaping up physically? Hoping he might get a game end of the year?
I got along for a look and IMO Silvagni shone like a beacon compared to every other participant.
Runs better than his dad and grandad - low bars to be sure but he does move well. Most impressive features were his clean ball handling and his ability to adjust to the ball in flight in marking contests. The only player who deserves to be promoted on the basis of what I saw on Sunday.
Jones and Jaksch showed their usual limitations with Liam unable to hold a mark but being very hard at it when the ball hits the ground and KJ being limited to straight line running with an inability to do much by way of second efforts. Of these two, KJ might have cleaner hands but is heavily reliant on the ball being kicked to his advantage on the lead whereas Jones is more suited to hitting the pack (in marking contests or on the ground) so Jones is probably better suited to the long bomb forward.
Of the others, nobody pushing for promotion although Tutt seems to do enough to keep his name on the fringes.
Whiley and Dick are useful VFL footballers but too slow for the AFL.
McCasker and Gowers show lots of dash and might be options in the future.
Sheehan looks like he hasn't played for a couple of years; Cam Wood seems to be a shadow of what he offered last year; Phillips was pushed around by the opposing ruckmen but might be more competitive at centre bounces.
Foster, DVR and Smith all appear to have some talent but need to do much much more.