+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Best 22 so far (/thread-4533.html)
Re: Best 22 so far - jeza - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 02:05 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:I think Fisher and Plowman will both play round 1, the latter did well in the best and fairest from memory and I just think Fisher will be persisted with and being a mate of Cripps
might help his cause too.
I couldn't fit them in.
B Caleb MARCHBANK Liam JONES Nic NEWMAN
HB Kade SIMPSON Jacob WEITERING Sam DOCHERTY
C Jack NEWNES Patrick CRIPPS Sam WALSH
HF David CUNINGHAM Harry MCKAY Jack MARTIN
F Mitch MCGOVERN Charlie CURNOW Eddie BETTS
R Matthew KREUZER Will SETTERFIELD Marc MURPHY
IC Jack SILVAGNI Michael GIBBONS Sam PETREVSKI-SETON
Levi CASBOULT
Re: Best 22 so far - ElwoodBlues1 - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 02:25 AM)jeza link Wrote:I couldn't fit them in.
B Caleb MARCHBANK Liam JONES Nic NEWMAN
HB Kade SIMPSON Jacob WEITERING Sam DOCHERTY
C Jack NEWNES Patrick CRIPPS Sam WALSH
HF David CUNINGHAM Harry MCKAY Jack MARTIN
F Mitch MCGOVERN Charlie CURNOW Eddie BETTS
R Matthew KREUZER Will SETTERFIELD Marc MURPHY
IC Jack SILVAGNI Michael GIBBONS Sam PETREVSKI-SETON
Levi CASBOULT
I think Fisher is ahead of Cuningham and Newnes in the pecking order, Plowman I think would get the nod ahead of Levi or even Jack.
Dont get me wrong I like your team as its well balanced and players like Levi and Jack earned their spots from last season but I'm not sure the selectors will
see it that way..
Re: Best 22 so far - capcom - 12-13-2019
Casboult easily in the starting lineup. Docherty? No.
Re: Best 22 so far - PaulP - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 03:00 AM)capcom link Wrote:Casboult easily in the starting lineup. Docherty? No.
Why no Docherty ?
Re: Best 22 so far - capcom - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 03:36 AM)PaulP link Wrote:Why no Docherty ?
Paul, I doubt he'll be ready and even if he is, he's gonna need quite some time to regain touch.
Re: Best 22 so far - JonHenry - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 02:23 AM)jeza link Wrote:Who goes out? Docherty / Simpson / Newman?
Simpson or Newman
Don’t get me wrong, I’m saying if everyone is absolutely 100%.
Re: Best 22 so far - jeza - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 04:44 AM)capcom link Wrote:Paul, I doubt he'll be ready and even if he is, he's gonna need quite some time to regain touch.
Charlie is unlikely to be ready. This is assuming everyone is fit.
Re: Best 22 so far - LP - 12-13-2019
I'll be gobsmacked, if after de-listing Daisy, that Newman isn't one of the 1st picked.
He's about the only aggressive player we've got in D50.
Re: Best 22 so far - kruddler - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 12:42 AM)jeza link Wrote:Ins and Outs for round 1 from our round 23 team 2019... maybe
OUT:
Deluca, Josh
Dow, Paddy
Fisher, Zac
Kennedy, Matthew
OBrien, Lochie
Plowman, Lachie
Thomas, Dale
IN:
Caleb MARCHBANK
Liam JONES
Sam DOCHERTY
Jack NEWNES
Jack MARTIN
Charlie CURNOW
Eddie BETTS
If everyone were available that would be a far stronger team. A lot stronger back and forward line.
A lot less relying on young midfielders to play out of position as forwards or back flanks.
Poor old Plow still can;t get any love.
He just finished 3rd in our B+F and people still want to boot him from the side.
He'll be picked. Marchy will need to earn his stripes back.
As for Willo which people keep bringing up.
Is he better than a 300+ gamer in Simpson?
Is he better than our (co)captain in Docherty?
Is he better than super consistent Newman?
He has some talent....but if people think he is displacing those boys, it'd be due to injury.
Re: Best 22 so far - LP - 12-13-2019
(12-13-2019, 10:47 AM)kruddler link Wrote:Poor old Plow still can;t get any love.
He just finished 3rd in our B+F and people still want to boot him from the side.
He'll be picked. Marchy will need to earn his stripes back.
x2, I'm not buying into this debate because most of the posts are just lists of favourite players with no regard to team format or function.
On game style, considering the coach his playing history and game style, I suspect Newman and Plowman are walk up starts.