+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon (/thread-2772.html)
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - Thryleon - 06-06-2016
Its not about rushing.
If SOS*2 is ready and performing as well as showing that he has the right stuff, he will get a game.
Thats all there is to it.
He kicks 4.2 and gets 20 disposals whilst taking 7 marks and that shows he is on his way to being ready.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - Gointocarlton - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 01:19 AM)Thryleon link Wrote:Its not about rushing.With the young fellas (KPs), its probably a little more complicated than doing what you have suggested in the 2's. Its a massive step up to AFL level for them from a physicality point of view. Jack is listed as 191kg and 93kg, I found the weight a little surprising. I saw him fairly close up at the Hall of Fame thingy and again at Etihad a few weeks ago, he didnt look 93kg to me. In any case, if they think he is ready physically, fine. I'd be surprised though.
If SOS*2 is ready and performing as well as showing that he has the right stuff, he will get a game.
Thats all there is to it.
He kicks 4.2 and gets 20 disposals whilst taking 7 marks and that shows he is on his way to being ready.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - cimm1979 - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 02:05 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:With the young fellas (KPs), its probably a little more complicated than doing what you have suggested in the 2's. Its a massive step up to AFL level for them from a physicality point of view. Jack is listed as 191kg and 93kg, I found the weight a little surprising. I saw him fairly close up at the Hall of Fame thingy and again at Etihad a few weeks ago, he didnt look 93kg to me. In any case, if they think he is ready physically, fine. I'd be surprised though.
I would have though 83 kilos when drafted.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - Thryleon - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 02:05 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:With the young fellas (KPs), its probably a little more complicated than doing what you have suggested in the 2's. Its a massive step up to AFL level for them from a physicality point of view. Jack is listed as 191kg and 93kg, I found the weight a little surprising. I saw him fairly close up at the Hall of Fame thingy and again at Etihad a few weeks ago, he didnt look 93kg to me. In any case, if they think he is ready physically, fine. I'd be surprised though.
I understand that, but that all depends on what role we get him to play.
i.e. 3rd tall leading forward, or better yet, a similar role to what Jed Lamb is playing and then play Lamb through the middle of the field.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - pinot - 06-06-2016
VFL has developed bodies as well - weak argument. If he is good enough to play then he should play
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - flyboy77 - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 03:24 AM)pinot link Wrote:VFL has developed bodies as well - weak argument. If he is good enough to play then he should play
Absolutely.
Gives Everitt/Walker something to think about.....
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - cimm1979 - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 03:24 AM)pinot link Wrote:VFL has developed bodies as well - weak argument. If he is good enough to play then he should play
This is an even weaker argument for selecting him in the firsts.
Big, usually slower and incapable of the full game pressure you get at the top level.
I'm sure there's 16 year olds who are ready for the top level but there are 20 year olds who need more time.
He cant run out a game, where do we play him?
The club has got every one of these calls right so far so I'll leave it to the experts.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - DJC - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 03:06 AM)cimm1979 link Wrote:I would have though 83 kilos when drafted.
His draft profile says 83kg and there's no way he has put on 10kg in 6 months. He looks closer to 73kg, wringing wet!
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - laj - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 02:05 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:With the young fellas (KPs), its probably a little more complicated than doing what you have suggested in the 2's. Its a massive step up to AFL level for them from a physicality point of view. Jack is listed as 191kg and 93kg, I found the weight a little surprising. I saw him fairly close up at the Hall of Fame thingy and again at Etihad a few weeks ago, he didnt look 93kg to me. In any case, if they think he is ready physically, fine. I'd be surprised though.
93kg? Really? Certainly looks bigger than when we drafted him but 93 surprises me.
Anyway, he's as ok as anyone to have a crack in the seniors.
Re: VFL Rd 9: Northern Blues vs Frankston at Ikon - Gointocarlton - 06-06-2016
(06-06-2016, 03:47 AM)DJC link Wrote:His draft profile says 83kg and there's no way he has put on 10kg in 6 months. He looks closer to 73kg, wringing wet!Dont shoot the messenger kiddies
http://www.carltonfc.com.au/player-profile/jack-silvagni