+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon (/thread-2201.html)
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - madbluboy - 08-14-2015
(08-13-2015, 11:50 PM)ItsOurTime link Wrote:If we win, and Brisbane push the bergers price up enough, and we jump Gold Coast - we could get pick 4.
Free agency is officially a farce if they get pick 2 as compo for Leunberger after we got nothing for Waite.
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - JonHenry - 08-14-2015
(08-14-2015, 03:38 AM)madbluboy link Wrote:Free agency is officially a farce if they get pick 2 as compo for Leunberger after we got nothing for Waite.
Not free agency, the AFL
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - hotspur - 08-14-2015
If Jones was playing then everyone would know we are tankingÂ
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - Baggers - 08-14-2015
(08-14-2015, 02:41 AM)shadesy link Wrote:Dont fear it.. embrace it.
Love the selections (except i would have Walsh for Davey). More games into kids, guys getting a good run at it and hopefully a nice competitive loss.
Best way to look at it. If we were vying for a position in the 8 our selections would, of course, be different. But we're not, we're at the bottom of the table and already looking to next year in terms of assessing who gets a guernsey at year's end and who gets traded and who gets the heave ho. Of course you play the kids. Of course you don't take the slightest risk with injured blokes. Of course you put injured blokes out for surgery. Of course you experiment.
To the cynical mind you could mount a conspiracy case for tanking but to me it looks as if we're doing exactly what we should be doing in the best long term interest of the club factoring in the reality of where we are right now. I still think we're in with a good chance to win tomorrow and against Melbourne and against GWS.
It's one of the main reasons when I was in Oz (back later in the year... yah!) to go see NBs games, to see who's coming through. Winning was great, but if we lost but a newbie shone - great stuff. If we win tomorrow night - great. But if we lose and we get another game into blokes who might not have otherwise gotten one - great, more preparation for 2016. If we get a look at someone under real heat in preparation for 2016 who might not have gotten a gig this year - great. And you can bet that the Aints, cheats.com.au, GCS and Dees are doing exactly the same thing but because there're not as close to the bottom as us and BrisVegas there is no tanking suspicion.
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - PassIt2Carrots - 08-14-2015
Well said Baggers. Looking forward to Holman, Whiley and Jaksch getting another go.
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - Thryleon - 08-14-2015
I don't want pick 1.
It never. Turns out to be the best player of that draft.
I want pick 2.
Let's get some wins.
It would be better for us if Jaksch kicks six goals, and we win by thirty after a dominant Whiley performance than to lose and get pick 1.
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - ElwoodBlues1 - 08-14-2015
I'd like pick 1 so we can nab a good player coming out of contract in the PSD and not have to trade for them...beating Brisbane doesnt count for much IMO and
I have my doubts on their winning intentions for this game anyway as they are in the same situation as us...
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - MilkIt - 08-14-2015
(08-14-2015, 06:20 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:I'd like pick 1 so we can nab a good player coming out of contract in the PSD and not have to trade for them...beating Brisbane doesnt count for much IMO and
I have my doubts on their winning intentions for this game anyway as they are in the same situation as us...
I agree on the PSD. Almost as good as having pick one in the National Draft. I could live with pick 2 as I still think we'll get Weitering but if we win we probably go ahead of Gold Coast and that's pick 3.
Let's not forget that we have to lose comfortably for the Lions to make up the % to go above us and get pick 1 as well.
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - LP - 08-14-2015
If you are picked at 2 you have a point to prove!
Re: R20 Brisbane v Carlton - Battle for the Spoon - PassIt2Carrots - 08-14-2015
(08-14-2015, 06:10 AM)Thryleon link Wrote:I don't want pick 1.
It never. Turns out to be the best player of that draft.
I want pick 2.
Let's get some wins.
It would be better for us if Jaksch kicks six goals, and we win by thirty after a dominant Whiley performance than to lose and get pick 1.
Agree.