+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Winning isn't everything (/thread-4293.html)
Re: Winning isn't everything - Lods - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 04:12 AM)PaulP link Wrote:W/L are only a part of a much bigger puzzle. We need to learn from the smart, professional clubs.
The problem is Paul that you cant complete this puzzle without one vital piece.
Wins!
It's rather bizarre really..
The win/ loss record is the reality.
The games 'we should have won' are the fantasy
The "we'll be right if we're just patient" is the prophecy.
The only way for things to play out as the 'patient' people and the 'impatient' ones wish is exactly the same thing...a winning side!
Re: Winning isn't everything - PaulP - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 04:25 AM)Lods link Wrote:The problem is Paul that you cant complete this puzzle without one vital piece.
Wins!
It's rather bizarre really..
The win/ loss record is the reality.
The games 'we should have won' are the fantasy
The "we'll be right if we're just patient" is the prophecy.
The only way for things to play out as the 'patient' people and the 'impatient' ones wish is exactly the same thing...a winning side!
What I wish for more than anything is a professionally run club, one that follows good precedent, good process and one that looks at things holistically. Understanding metrics beyond W/L is not fantasy. Otherwise Hardwick, Buckley and Thompson would have been sacked long ago. Understanding that losses against GC, Hawks, Pies were due to inexperience, luck, umpiring etc. is not fantasy. We cannot be right in each game up to our teeth, give Bolton no credit for that, then when we lose in the dying seconds, say he's crap.
Look back over the last 20 years, and tell me which clubs change coaches every 5 seconds - the good ones, or the crap ones ?
Re: Winning isn't everything - ElwoodBlues1 - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 04:12 AM)PaulP link Wrote:The same folks on here calling for Bolton's head, or putting him on notice, are the same who would have called for Hardwick's, Buckley's and Thompson's heads if they supported those teams :
Geelong 2000-2006 - up and down like a yo-yo
Pies - 2012 -2017 - backwards for 6 seasons, despite a fantastic midfield
Tigers - bundled out in 3 consecutive EF's (13,14,15), then 13th in 2016.
W/L are only a part of a much bigger puzzle. We need to learn from the smart, professional clubs.
None of those teams were basket cases, wooden spoon material etc from a scorched earth rebuild......as much as SOS has said its easy to build a midpack team thats where those clubs launched from.
Scorched earth rebuilds are unchartered waters, there isnt a owners manual that you can refer to or any statistical basis to suggest what is right or wrong.
Re: Winning isn't everything - PaulP - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 04:52 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:None of those teams were basket cases, wooden spoon material etc from a scorched earth rebuild......as much as SOS has said its easy to build a midpack team thats where those clubs launched from.
Scorched earth rebuilds are unchartered waters, there isnt a owners manual that you can refer to or any statistical basis to suggest what is right or wrong.
I agree, but I wish to make the following 2 points :
- your post is precisely why we need to see the process through, with the main protagonists on board.
- the fact remains, that there were a large contingent of Pies and Tigers supporters who wanted Hardwick and Buckley gone, even though those clubs took a much less risky approach.
Re: Winning isn't everything - Lods - 05-15-2019
Yep the close losses are a fantasy.
They're not real wins, they're wins that didn't happen
They're excuses, valid ones in some cases.
They give us a bit of hope.
But what they give us hope for is that we can give a good effort on the day.
They wont show up in record books and probably wont be remembered by us in ten years time when we think back on this period.
I remember Blight kicking a goal from the opposite goal square, I remember Kernahan hitting the behind post for a draw, Fevola missed one for a few metres out one year....I don't remember the reasons for too many more close losses.
Bolton gets credit for the way we've played in most games this year.
But the difference between a close loss and a close win is as wide as the Grand Canyon.
Re: Winning isn't everything - Lods - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 04:58 AM)PaulP link Wrote:I agree, but I wish to make the following 2 points :
- your post is precisely why we need to see the process through, with the main protagonists on board.
- the fact remains, that there were a large contingent of Pies and Tigers supporters who wanted Hardwick and Buckley gone, even though those clubs took a much less risky approach.
This probably goes to the heart of things...
Some see Bolton and the process as inseparable.
I don't see it that way because he came late to the process.
And my worry is that others who were more invested at the beginning would see it the same way.
It's why I have concerns that if we don't start winning games there is an easy target before others are held accountable.
Re: Winning isn't everything - Thryleon - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 04:52 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:None of those teams were basket cases, wooden spoon material etc from a scorched earth rebuild......as much as SOS has said its easy to build a midpack team thats where those clubs launched from.
Scorched earth rebuilds are unchartered waters, there isnt a owners manual that you can refer to or any statistical basis to suggest what is right or wrong.
Given thats the case EB1, does that mean that we need to look at a newbie team entering the competition as a point of reference?
Given the concessions afforded to them, that would mean we need additional patience to go with that.
Effectively, we are talking about GWS winning last in 2012, 2013, 16th in 2014, 11th in 2015, and then finals football.
Have done more of the Gold Coast version rebuild?
17th, 17th, 14th, 12th, 16th, 15th, 17th, 17th....
What about Freo?
It took them 8 years to play finals....
Anything predating then is a little bit difficult as a basis for comparison as the competition was too different regarding player movement (form 4's for the addition of Brisbane, West Coast and Adelaide).
Food for thought everyone:
https://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-02-15/clarko-almost-sacked-in-2010
Imagine they had lost that day. A 3 point margin is one kick. One kick resulting in a goal. To change 1 result. Had they ditched Clarkson, we would have no idea how it would pan out from that day forward, but the one thing I can determine, is that one result SHOULDNT be that important to Brendan Boltons position. Its not like we won a flag two years ago.
Re: Winning isn't everything - PaulP - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 05:04 AM)Lods link Wrote:This probably goes to the heart of things...
Some see Bolton and the process as inseparable.
I don't see it that way because he came late to the process.
And my worry is that others who were more invested at the beginning would see it the same way.
It's why I have concerns that if we don't start winning games there is an easy target before others are held accountable.
And there it is. The Carlton way, the Demons way, the Saints way. Not the Pies, Tigers, Hawks or Cats way. And that's the difference. Not looking for an easy target, but actually looking for answers.
Re: Winning isn't everything - cookie2 - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 05:15 AM)PaulP link Wrote:And there it is. The Carlton way, the Demons way, the Saints way. Not the Pies, Tigers, Hawks or Cats way. And that's the difference. Not looking for an easy target, but actually looking for answers.
Well we don't know that that is still the case do we? People on here and in the media speculate and opine about it based probably on actions taken in the past by the club. There has been no indication from the club itself as yet as to what might be in the minds of the management apart from sticking with the plan. It is a bit premature then to talk about "The Carlton Way" in the old sense in respect of this situation don't you think? Certainly the idea of a ground up rebuild is not the Carlton Way of past eras.
Re: Winning isn't everything - PaulP - 05-15-2019
(05-15-2019, 05:25 AM)cookie2 link Wrote:Well we don't know that that is still the case do we? People on here and in the media speculate and opine about it based probably on actions taken in the past by the club. There has been no indication from the club itself as yet as to what might be in the minds of the management apart from sticking with the plan. It is a bit premature then to talk about "The Carlton Way" in the old sense in respect of this situation don't you think? Certainly the idea of a ground up rebuild is not the Carlton Way of past eras.
We'll find out soon enough - is it a real, thorough rebuild, or just a new facade over the existing structure ?