+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: John Nicholls Medal-2015 (/thread-2313.html)
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - PassIt2Carrots - 09-17-2015
(09-17-2015, 09:26 PM)madbluboy link Wrote:He was much better than last year but I wouldn't have had him that high.
Grew another leg when Mick left. Any personal issues there?
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - madbluboy - 09-17-2015
(09-17-2015, 09:36 PM)PassIt2Carrots link Wrote:Grew another leg when Mick left. Any personal issues there?
I agree with that, he liked the freedom Barker gave him but are we to ignore Yarran and Henderson went the other way after Mick left?
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - PaulP - 09-17-2015
(09-17-2015, 12:40 PM)Wet Willie link Wrote:After Round 23 (Final Scores):
Patrick Cripps 68
Marc Murphy 67
Zach Touhy
Tom Bell 57
Ed Curnow 57
Sam Docherty 48
Thanks for all the updates WW.
Fantastic win by Crippa. B+F, R/U in the Rising Star. Very happy the recruiters at least got this one so, so right. Would've been nice to see a tie between him and Murph.
Surprised to see 2E poll so high, and Doc poll so low. And Curnow ? How would've thought ?
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - Brettie - 09-17-2015
(09-17-2015, 07:56 AM)shadesy link Wrote:Rowe is my Smoky for Top 5.
Geez shadesy - I usually rate your posts, but this one was an unmitigated shocker. Rowe stunk the joint up for about 3/4 of the year.....if he had've finished top 10, serious questions would've had to be asked.
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - PassIt2Carrots - 09-17-2015
(09-17-2015, 09:46 PM)madbluboy link Wrote:I agree with that, he liked the freedom Barker gave him but are we to ignore Yarran and Henderson went the other way after Mick left?
I reckon Hendo has been poo for quite sometime TBH. Most overrated player to play at our club for the last 2-3 years. Even under Ratten he was okay, showed promise but never really fulfilled it.
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - Micky0 - 09-17-2015
http://m.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/patrick-cripps-wins-carlton-best-and-fairest-20150917-gjp6vd.html
He thanked his mentors - Jamo and GIBBS! Wow.
So bell won a few awards but apparently still off to Brisbane :-\
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - PassIt2Carrots - 09-17-2015
Yep I noticed in our last win against Melbourne he seemed to celebrate extra hard with Jamo, I guess that explains it.
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - Lods - 09-17-2015
1. Patrick Cripps 68 votes (Games 20)
2. Marc Murphy 67 (Games 19)
3. Zach Tuohy 64 (Games 22)
4. Tom Bell 57 (Games 22)
4. Ed Curnow 57 (Games 22)
6. Sam Docherty 48 (Games 19)
7. Kade Simpson 45 (Games 20)
8. Andrejs Everitt 37 (Games 22)
9. Simon White 35 (Games 14)
10. Andrew Carrazzo 23 (Games 16)
Number of games is obviously a factor....it's why there is actually even more of a gap between the top 2 and the rest.
Following instructions or filling a role (sometimes at the expense of your own game) would be another it's why the count sometimes throws up the odd "who would have thought...." result.
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - ItsOurTime - 09-17-2015
(09-17-2015, 10:14 PM)Lods link Wrote:1. Patrick Cripps 68 votes (Games 20)
2. Marc Murphy 67 (Games 19)
3. Zach Tuohy 64 (Games 22)
4. Tom Bell 57 (Games 22)
4. Ed Curnow 57 (Games 22)
6. Sam Docherty 48 (Games 19)
7. Kade Simpson 45 (Games 20)
8. Andrejs Everitt 37 (Games 22)
9. Simon White 35 (Games 14)
10. Andrew Carrazzo 23 (Games 16)
1. Murphy - NO
2. Doc - NO
3 Krooz - NO
4. Cripps - NO
5. Simpson - NO
6. Judd - NO
7. Bell - NO
8. Curnow - NO
9. Buckley - NO
10. Everitt - NO
Any only picked 7 of the top 10
Well off. Oh well, at least I didn't pluck Rowe for 5th
Re: John Nicholls Medal-2015 - Lods - 09-17-2015
We're not bad judges
..generally ;DJohn Nicholls 2015 Top 10
1. Patrick Cripps 68 votes
2. Marc Murphy 67
3. Zach Tuohy 64
4. Tom Bell 57
4. Ed Curnow 57
6. Sam Docherty 48
7. Kade Simpson 45
8. Andrejs Everitt 37
9. Simon White 35
10. Andrew Carrazzo 23
The final standings for the Jim Park Medal for 2015:
1- Cripps, Patrick (1)
2 - Murphy, Marc (2)
3 - Bell, Tom (=4)
4- Docherty, Sam (6)
5- Simpson, Kade (7)
6 - Kreuzer, Matthew (0)
7 - Curnow, Edward (=4)
8 - Tuohy, Zach (3)
9- Judd, Chris (0)
10- Everitt, Andrejs (8 )