+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Around The Grounds (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-7.html)
+--- Forum: The Sports Desk (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-27.html)
+--- Thread: Jarryd Hayne (/thread-2273.html)
Re: Jarryd Hayne - kruddler - 10-23-2015
(10-23-2015, 07:37 AM)Lods link Wrote:I'll admit I know very little about it .
So yep you called it pretty right.
The thing is that punt return thing is a bit of a wanky position.
He'd be a lot better just running the ball but it looks like there are a couple of pretty competent blokes in front of him.
It is a wanky position, but that is the reason he made the team. If he can't do that, he's got no hope.
The thing with running the ball is you can't fumble it. If you do, your career will be very short. The fact he keeps fumbling on punt returns means coaches are not likely to take a chance with him on offense.
Re: Jarryd Hayne - mateinone - 10-23-2015
In fairness to him, he has made two rookie mistakes. In one he didn't protect the ball, the other he didn't read the drop/swirl.
I think they will persist with him a bit longer, because he is a very talented athlete and they know this, but there is work to do. He was also shown up with not covering the quarterback, but he isn't the first running back or in Tackle/Guard to do that either, or else we would seen a QB ever sacked.
I think another major drop though in his next game and it would be thanks, but it isn't working.
If he was born a yank playing the game he would likely be an absolute superstar of the game, that is why they will keep trying I think.
That and they are sh1te anyway. Just about the worst team in the country, so his mistakes are not costing games any more than other players on the team, just the spotlight is right on him.
At least that is my take on it.
They could just cut him as well
Re: Jarryd Hayne - kruddler - 10-23-2015
(10-23-2015, 07:52 AM)mateinone link Wrote:In fairness to him, he has made two rookie mistakes. In one he didn't protect the ball, the other he didn't read the drop/swirl.
I think they will persist with him a bit longer, because he is a very talented athlete and they know this, but there is work to do. He was also shown up with not covering the quarterback, but he isn't the first running back or in Tackle/Guard to do that either, or else we would seen a QB ever sacked.
I think another major drop though in his next game and it would be thanks, but it isn't working.
If he was born a yank playing the game he would likely be an absolute superstar of the game, that is why they will keep trying I think.
That and they are sh1te anyway. Just about the worst team in the country, so his mistakes are not costing games any more than other players on the team, just the spotlight is right on him.
At least that is my take on it.
They could just cut him as well
...and thats what i was saying about him. He has so much to learn just to catch up to high school guys in terms of basics.
Even IF he gets that up to scratch and he hasn't been cut in the meantime, he still needs to leapfrog blokes who are likely faster, stronger and more knowledgeable than him to even make an impact.
Never knocked the bloke for what he has been able to achieve, but things are so far stacked against him, that reality is that he will not live up to even half the amount of hype surrounding him. Which was my point.
Re: Jarryd Hayne - DJC - 10-23-2015
I reckon that he has achieved far more than most folk expected and I suspect that he will go on to bigger and better things. It's not going to happen overnight though and he will have to address some basic skill errors if he is to progress.
Clearly, those that gave him the opportunity to play NFL understood his limitations and his upside and I suspect that their assessment is a lot closer to the mark than that of the armchair critics - Kruddler's expertise notwithstanding
Re: Jarryd Hayne - Thryleon - 10-23-2015
Just quietly the only reason he has a spot is because he is an Aussie convert and gets us talking more about the game down under.
Re: Jarryd Hayne - DJC - 10-24-2015
(10-23-2015, 11:52 AM)Thryleon link Wrote:Just quietly the only reason he has a spot is because he is an Aussie convert and gets us talking more about the game down under.
I really don't think they give a fat rat's clacker about whether we're talking about the game. The potential market here is minuscule compared to what they have now and they are too hard-nosed to consider novelty value.
Perhaps he was cheap ???
Re: Jarryd Hayne - Lods - 10-31-2015
Well Kruddler was right.
You don't get to drop the ball too often ;D
Sky News reporting....
Hayne has been 'released' by the 49ers
Get the first plane home Jarryd....and we'll rookie draft you
( Edit: It seems as though the 49ers have dropped Hayne to elevate another player. They can drop Hayne back to their non-playing squad or he can be picked up by another team.)
http://www.foxsports.com.au/us-sports/nfl/jarryd-hayne-san-francisco-49ers-australian-waived-to-make-way-for-running-back-kendall-gaskins/story-fnp3l4e4-1227589708199
Re: Jarryd Hayne - LP - 11-01-2015
It's over for Hayne, he dropped the ball!
Re: Jarryd Hayne - ElwoodBlues1 - 11-01-2015
Hayne will get picked up by another team or go to the 49ers practice squad.....he still has a chance to make it...
Re: Jarryd Hayne - DJC - 11-01-2015
Some folk are suggesting that Hayne is a scapegoat for the 49ers' poor form:
Quote:Former St. Louis Cardinals defensive end Colin Scotts was furious with the San Francisco franchise for culling Hayne, saying he was being blamed for the whole team’s poor performances.
“Jarryd was the first scapegoat, it’s devastating to me. They’ve made a massive mistake,” Scotts said while speaking on Fox Sports News.
“If I showed you last week when he missed a block I can show you a dozen other players who are missing blocks also on just one play, but he gets amplified because he’s Australian and they say he’s inexperienced and gets made a scapegoat.
“They are a team that is desperate. They’re panicking, they’re looking for someone to blame.
“49ers, I’m sorry, mate, but I’m disgusted.”
Hayne is still positive about his future and I reckon, if attitude is anything to go on, he will succeed.