+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Give Harry a go (/thread-3691.html)
Re: Give Harry a go - madbluboy - 03-28-2018
(03-27-2018, 12:10 PM)DJC link Wrote:So far Rance has had two marks, three kicks and two handpasses, and one of those resulted in a goal to us.
Casboult has had 10 hitouts and has brought the ball to ground in our forward line on four occasions.
I suspect that Rance will accumulate most of his possessions when Casboult spends more time in the ruck, but don't let that spoil your adoration for blokes who play for other teams MBB.
SOS had 8 disposals in the 95 Grand Final. Ablett must have done a great job according to you.
Re: Give Harry a go - kruddler - 03-28-2018
Harry should get a game or 2, VFL form is far from convincing one way or another.
Delivery would be substandard.
Grounds are substandard.
even the amount of develivery could be substandard.
Get him in the 1's, give him at least a couple of weeks and reassess.
As for Patty Kerr, if he is up and about, he could replace Jack. Similar players IMO.
Re: Give Harry a go - cookie2 - 03-28-2018
(03-28-2018, 06:57 AM)kruddler link Wrote:Harry should get a game or 2, VFL form is far from convincing one way or another.
Delivery would be substandard.
Grounds are substandard.
even the amount of develivery could be substandard.
Get him in the 1's, give him at least a couple of weeks and reassess.
As for Patty Kerr, if he is up and about, he could replace Jack. Similar players IMO.
Tend to agree. We have to try and press on with him and give him a go when a spot is available.
Re: Give Harry a go - Lods - 03-28-2018
If we use that criteria though ...everyone should get a game.
In his senior appearances so far Harry has shown glimpses but only glimpses.
If Kreuzer doesn't come up maybe he gets a chance...otherwise he stays in the VFL
Re: Give Harry a go - Jack Burton - 03-28-2018
Would feel a bit like clutching at straws to give Harry a game based on his exposed form. Hope he has a couple of good games in the vfl, then bring him in
Re: Give Harry a go - cookie2 - 03-28-2018
(03-28-2018, 08:01 AM)Lods link Wrote:If we use that criteria though ...everyone should get a game.
In his senior appearances so far Harry has shown glimpses but only glimpses.
If Kreuzer doesn't come up maybe he gets a chance...otherwise he stays in the VFL
If Kreuz and Levi are available then fair comment - but I would give Harry a go if either were not available.
Re: Give Harry a go - kruddler - 03-28-2018
(03-28-2018, 08:01 AM)Lods link Wrote:If we use that criteria though ...everyone should get a game.
In his senior appearances so far Harry has shown glimpses but only glimpses.
If Kreuzer doesn't come up maybe he gets a chance...otherwise he stays in the VFL
Its from a team need point of view.
SPS last year played R1 but he hadn't played a JLT game and obviously had no other exposed form to go by being a new draftee. He played...and played and played. It worked. He was required due to a shortage of mids who could play.
We have a shortage of key forwards who can hit the scoreboard. What have we got to lose? A game?
Re: Give Harry a go - Lods - 03-28-2018
(03-28-2018, 08:29 AM)kruddler link Wrote:Its from a team need point of view.
SPS last year played R1 but he hadn't played a JLT game and obviously had no other exposed form to go by being a new draftee. He played...and played and played. It worked. He was required due to a shortage of mids who could play.
We have a shortage of key forwards who can hit the scoreboard. What have we got to lose? A game?
SPS was our round one draft pick...he didn't play JLT last year because he was injured.
McKay has played seniors...he wasn't considered up to a round one spot.
He may get a game but it will probably be due to an injury.
Hopefully he grabs his chance.
Re: Give Harry a go - PaulP - 03-28-2018
Is anyone else getting a slightly uneasy feeling that McKay might be the new Kristian Jaksch ? I know it's early days, but all the talk worries me a little.......
Re: Give Harry a go - Lods - 03-28-2018
(03-28-2018, 09:13 AM)PaulP link Wrote:Is anyone else getting a slightly uneasy feeling that McKay might be the new Kristian Jaksch ? I know it's early days, but all the talk worries me a little.......
I'm not overly concerned yet as big KPP's often take a while...but it would have been nice to see him demanding a spot first up.
Hopefully we'll look back at the end of the season and there will be a handy 20-25 goal haul alongside his name.