+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: A List with Real Potential (/thread-3041.html)
Re: A List with Real Potential - flyboy77 - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 10:28 AM)jeza link Wrote:I agree we've gone a bit "swing man" crazy but Curnow / McKay / Silvagni / Casboult are all forwards. Curnow is a full forward. Cannot see him as a mid at all. Can't wait to see him develop.
Rowe was a forward at Norwood, pure & simple. At CFC he's plugged holes. he played 90 odd games for Norwood and kicked 120 odd goals...... better return than most on our list!
Re: A List with Real Potential - ElwoodBlues1 - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 10:40 AM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Rowe was a forward at Norwood, pure & simple. At CFC he's plugged holes. he played 90 odd games for Norwood and kicked 120 odd goals...... better return than most on our list!
Yep played CHF and did a bit of rucking, better ruckman than given credit for and is a reasonably straight kick for goal.....squeeze is going to be on down back with Marchbank coming into the team and I'd prefer Weitering to stay down back and Rowe to be moved forward if we need another option especially as Harry McKay probably needs some time to develop in the NB's after missing most of last season..
With Byrne out till the middle of the season it will be interesting to see if we promote a rookie and who....my tip is they didnt recruit Alex Silvagni to play too many n the NB's and he might end up in the seniors earlier than expected..
Re: A List with Real Potential - townsendcalling - 11-28-2016
Of course, few years ago we had a young blonde No 36 who played off a half back flank and he turned into a fairly handy Centre Half Forward!!
Re: A List with Real Potential - ElwoodBlues1 - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 10:52 AM)townsendcalling link Wrote:Of course, few years ago we had a young blonde No 36 who played off a half back flank and he turned into a fairly handy Centre Half Forward!!
A fairly robust individual was No 36..dont think Weitering for example is as durable and needs to be managed in a more conservative fashion at least early in his career...
Re: A List with Real Potential - cookie2 - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 10:40 AM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Rowe was a forward at Norwood, pure & simple. At CFC he's plugged holes. he played 90 odd games for Norwood and kicked 120 odd goals...... better return than most on our list!
You're right FB, Rowe may just be the one to go forward with Silvagni (COS) coming into the defence. This would cover us until the younger guys develop and allow Levi to be tried as a Forward/Ruck?
Re: A List with Real Potential - DJC - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 11:13 AM)cookie2 link Wrote:You're right FB, Rowe may just be the one to go forward with Silvagni (COS) coming into the defence. This would cover us until the younger guys develop and allow Levi to be tried as a Forward/Ruck?
I know Rowe did a decent job as a fill in forward/ruck when Kreuzer and Casboult were injured but he really hasn't been a success when tried as a permanent forward. You certainly couldn't have Rowe and Casboult in the same forward line.
Rowe's best work is done minding the opposition's key forward and that's where he should stay. Our other tall/medium defenders like White, Weitering and probably Marchbank would be better options as forwards.
Re: A List with Real Potential - northernblue - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 07:17 AM)kruddler link Wrote:Rowe can play forward, but is best as a backman.
Weitering can play forward, but is best as a backman.
Plowman can play forward, but is best as a backman.
Marchbank can play forward, but is best as a backman.
Jaksch can play forward, but is best as a backman.
White can play forward, but is best as a backman.
Any danger we can get someone who is a better forward than they are a backman?
I see what you did there...
Where's Fev ?
????????
Re: A List with Real Potential - northernblue - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 11:26 AM)DJC link Wrote:I know Rowe did a decent job as a fill in forward/ruck when Kreuzer and Casboult were injured but he really hasn't been a success when tried as a permanent forward. You certainly couldn't have Rowe and Casboult in the same forward line.
Rowe's best work is done minding the opposition's key forward and that's where he should stay. Our other tall/medium defenders like White, Weitering and probably Marchbank would be better options as forwards.
Tend to agree DJC
Re: A List with Real Potential - cookie2 - 11-28-2016
(11-28-2016, 11:26 AM)DJC link Wrote:I know Rowe did a decent job as a fill in forward/ruck when Kreuzer and Casboult were injured but he really hasn't been a success when tried as a permanent forward. You certainly couldn't have Rowe and Casboult in the same forward line.
Rowe's best work is done minding the opposition's key forward and that's where he should stay. Our other tall/medium defenders like White, Weitering and probably Marchbank would be better options as forwards.
You could be right about Rowe DJC , but we really haven't been delivering the ball consistently well into F50 for a looong time so any forward would find it tough. With an improved midfield that could well change. WRT Levi, his biggest problem is his kicking as we all know, so however well F50 delivery may be improved that would be of no use in his case if he can't improve in that area. He may well do that but we need a plan B if he doesn't.
Having Rowe as another viable forward option would only be a good thing IMO.
Re: A List with Real Potential - Lods - 11-28-2016
Bolton...."Why all the backmen SOS. Don't we need forwards?"
SOS ... "I was fullback of the century I just like defenders!"
These guys have a plan, a strategy, that's a lot more complicated than this.
They'll be pretty aware of how existing players and the new recruits will fit into the side and the roles they will play.
Those roles may differ significantly from our perceptions of who's a defender and who is not.
The drafting of these players will have been done with a lot more thinking than..."You can never have too many backmen"
We're looking at this from a distance.
They're looking at it from the inside.... with months of preparation, discussion and decision.