+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne (/thread-4797.html)
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - LP - 07-22-2020
(07-22-2020, 05:39 AM)crashlander date Wrote:Cottrell has been impressing in the twos, although our defence has been pretty good.Cottrell is more than a defender, some of his better VFL games made use of his run off the wing, although he was named on the HBF he hardly started there more than a couple of times.
With some rotations expected, at AFL level I can almost see Cottrell in a defensive small forward roll, he can offer significant tackling and rundown ability. Maybe the go is to put Martin into the Betts role, give Cottrell a defensive small forward roll, let Betts have a week off and give Gibbons some more midfield time.
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - ElwoodBlues1 - 07-22-2020
(07-22-2020, 05:39 AM)crashlander link Wrote:<1>Last week Marc Pittonet had his least effective game by a long way. Apart from one small patch, he was generally beaten on the day.This is a very winnable game, Not sure I would be getting too cute with selection and bringing 1st gamers in...Nth are down but not out and still have a few decent players who could trouble us and take advantage of any newbies.
It made a big difference in the end, as Port's ruckman got so much of the ball.
Goldstein provides a challenge that we have to really work at. if he dominates, then we are trouble, no matter how poor they have been of late.
What are our options?
[1] Trust Pitto: has stood up to the challenge so far, even with last week's poor game.
[2] Maybe we could ruck Jones? Jones is not likely to win many taps, but he competes well ans won't let his man get away with the single free possession.
[3] Bring de Koning in: I don't think he is ready yet, but his athleticism, his marking and his leap provides more options than our one dimensional ruck unit so far.
I honestly don't know which way we should go, but we really need to put some time into this.
<2> A couple of our players have had less than stellar weeks lately. Guys like Cuningham and Newnes, to mention just a few. Do we stay with them, knowing that they both can play much better, or do we blood some newchums who could prove a difference?
I'd be tempted to bring in a guy like Honey, who could just do enough extraordinary stuff to be a match winner and who won't take any crap.
Cottrell has been impressing in the twos, although our defence has been pretty good.
or do we 'strengthen' the midield? Polson has been good. Dow?
Think we will stick with the Pittonet/Casboult ruck combo...you would expect Goldstein to take the points but as long as Pitto can negate him to just an average game its job done.
Ed Curnow has to take Higgins IMO, McDonald or Dumont will probably get Cripps and If my memory serves me right I think the latter has done ok on the skipper in the past.
McGovern might have a easier time of it this week, Nth's defense apart from Tarrant isnt start studded and likely opponents for the Guv could be McMillan or Pittard, he should over power both and providing he doesnt let them do too much rebounding he could have one of his better games.
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - Gointocarlton - 07-22-2020
(07-22-2020, 05:39 AM)crashlander link Wrote:<1>Last week Marc Pittonet had his least effective game by a long way. Apart from one small patch, he was generally beaten on the day.Agree on Pitto. Pitto / Levi combo works ok, wouldn't want to see Jones in the ruck, leave the back 6 as it is, back it in.
It made a big difference in the end, as Port's ruckman got so much of the ball.
Goldstein provides a challenge that we have to really work at. if he dominates, then we are trouble, no matter how poor they have been of late.
What are our options?
[1] Trust Pitto: has stood up to the challenge so far, even with last week's poor game.
[2] Maybe we could ruck Jones? Jones is not likely to win many taps, but he competes well ans won't let his man get away with the single free possession.
[3] Bring de Koning in: I don't think he is ready yet, but his athleticism, his marking and his leap provides more options than our one dimensional ruck unit so far.
I honestly don't know which way we should go, but we really need to put some time into this.
<2> A couple of our players have had less than stellar weeks lately. Guys like Cuningham and Newnes, to mention just a few. Do we stay with them, knowing that they both can play much better, or do we blood some newchums who could prove a difference?
I'd be tempted to bring in a guy like Honey, who could just do enough extraordinary stuff to be a match winner and who won't take any crap.
Cottrell has been impressing in the twos, although our defence has been pretty good.
or do we 'strengthen' the midield? Polson has been good. Dow?
Agree on TDK, not sure if he is ready or not. I'd guess Goldy is the not the right debut opponent for him.
Agree on Cunningham and Newnes, happy to see guys like Honey, Cottrel, Moore given a try.
Absolutely no on Polson, I never want to see him in the Seniors ever again. Too small, not enough skill, not enough mongrel, we know what he will bring, SFA. VFA player at best, no point going to that well again.
Dow I am happy to give a go when he is over the knee injury but he is also not impressing me with his disposal. Then again, he couldnt be worse than Kennedy (who I have been a massive fan of) at the moment. He was bloody terrible v Port.
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - ElwoodBlues1 - 07-22-2020
Jy Simpkin looking like he is out also for Nth.. and Thomas for the season.
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - Gointocarlton - 07-22-2020
(07-22-2020, 11:16 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:Jy Simpkin looking like he is out also for Nth.. and Thomas for the season.Gee I hope we don't do a 94 final when Hocking Couch Bairstow Mansfield and Stoneham were out!!
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - ElwoodBlues1 - 07-22-2020
(07-22-2020, 11:28 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:Gee I hope we don't do a 94 final when Hocking Couch Bairstow Mansfield and Stoneham were out!!We should win with one leg in the air, but it's going to be mighty embarrassing if we don't.
Was it some kid called Lord who kicked a bag in that game..?
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - Gointocarlton - 07-22-2020
(07-22-2020, 11:51 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:We should win with one leg in the air, but it's going to be mighty embarrassing if we don't.You mean God, kicked 6. Mensch 3, Aaron Lord kicked 1.
Was it some kid called Lord who kicked a bag in that game..?
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - Gointocarlton - 07-22-2020
FC just reported Stocker has returned home from the hub to be with family.
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - ElwoodBlues1 - 07-22-2020
(07-22-2020, 12:19 PM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:You mean God, kicked 6. Mensch 3, Aaron Lord kicked 1.I remember Lord playing well..
Re: Pre game discussion: AFL 2020 Rd 8: Carlton vs North Melbourne - Gointocarlton - 07-23-2020
No Change