+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Jim Park Analysis 2024 (/thread-6406.html)
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - crashlander - 08-16-2024
AFL 2024 Rd 21: Carlton vs Collingwood
Another game we should have won, but didn't. Very frustrating.
Trends:
[1] There were 9 voters this round, which was disappointing. Please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate.
[2] The rating was a 7.63, which is almost an C-. There was also a very large spread in the ratings; some of us were very dissatisfied.
[3] 15 players managed a mention this week. This is becoming the norm, something I am not disappointed about.
[4] The average vote this week was 26, which is low. Not many voters, so not many votes.
[5] 5 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which was positive. We usually win with such contributions.
[6] George Hewett and Patrick Cripps tied for top spot this week, both managing 220 votes.
[7] One player managed votes from everyone this week: George Hewett. Cripps missed from 1 voter, as did Weitering and Elijah Hollands.
[8] Elijah Hollands was the main youngster to make a decent contribution. The rest were pretty quiet, but a lot of players were not as significant as they could be.
[9] Our forwards didn't have a lot of impact this week. Most votes came from the midfield and defence.
Votes:
Cripps, Patrick 220
Hewett, George 220
Weitering, Jacob 136
Hollands, Elijah 119
McGovern, Mitchell 102
Newman, Nicholas 76
Kemp, Brodie 58
Walsh, Sam 51
Saad, Adam 34
Motlop, Jesse 34
Fogarty, Lachlan 25
Acres, Blake 25
Hollands, Oliver 17
Kennedy, Matthew 13
Martin, Jack 4
Progressive Voting:
Patrick Cripps 5060
Sam Walsh 2622
Tom de Koning 2406
Jacob Weitering 1815
Harry McKay 1729
Nic Newman 1524
George Hewett 1492
Charlie Curnow 1290
Blake Acres 1260
Adam Saad 805
Matthew Kennedy 742
Elijah Hollands 741
Mitch McGovern 731
Marc Pittonet 634
Alex Cincotta 481
Brodie Kemp 404
Zac Williams 360
Matthew Owies 345
Adam Cerra 296
Jordan Boyd 228
Matthew Cottrell 203
Lachlan Fogarty 199
Oliver Hollands 146
Orazio Fantasia 113
Jack Carroll 79
Lewis Young 73
Lachlan Cowan 67
Jesse Motlop 54
David Cuningham 13
Jack Martin 4
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - crashlander - 08-23-2024
AFL 2024 Rd 22: Carlton vs Hawthorn
Our worst performance for the year. Losing half a dozen players didn't help either.
Trends:
[1] There were 6 voters this round, which is the equal lowest in my time doing this. Granted that we were terrible, but we really need more voters. Please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate. It makes our statistics more reliable. It is a part of the CSC experience.
[2] The rating was a 5.11, which is an F. This sort of score hasn't been seen since the 'bad old days'.
[3] 12 players managed a mention this week. In past years, this wouldn't be bad, but in these days of efforts from most players, it is low.
[4] The average vote this week was 17. I've never seen an average score this low.
[5] 2 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which was very low. Not many voters, not many scores.
[6] Matthew Kennedy stood out for top spot this week, managing 294 votes.
[7][limegreen]Two[/color][/b] player managed votes from everyone this week: Kennedy and Acres
[8] Ollie Hollands was the main youngster to make a decent contribution. Lachie Cowan wasn't bad either.
[9] Our forwards didn't have a lot of impact this week. Most votes came from the midfield and defence.
Votes:
Kennedy, Matthew 294
Acres, Blake 128
Cripps, Patrick 77
Hollands, Oliver 77
Newman, Nicholas 51
Cowan, Lachlan 34
Hewett, George 30
Pittonet, Marc 26
Weitering, Jacob 17
Walsh, Sam 17
Saad, Adam 9
McKay, Harrison 9
Progressive voting:
Patrick Cripps 5136
Sam Walsh 2639
Tom de Koning 2406
Jacob Weitering 1833
Harry McKay 1738
Nic Newman 1575
George Hewett 1522
Blake Acres 1387
Charlie Curnow 1290
Matthew Kennedy 1036
Adam Saad 814
Elijah Hollands 741
Mitch McGovern 731
Marc Pittonet 659
Alex Cincotta 481
Brodie Kemp 404
Zac Williams 360
Matthew Owies 345
Adam Cerra 296
Jordan Boyd 228
Ollie Hollands 223
Matthew Cottrell 203
Lachie Fogarty 199
Orazio Fantasia 116
Lachie Cowan 101
Jack Carroll 79
Lewis Young 73
Jesse Motlop 53
David Cuningham 13
Jack Martin 5
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - DJC - 08-23-2024
I didn’t vote for the Hawthorn game Crash. I had another commitment that prevented me from watching the game live and I just couldn’t bring myself to watch a replay. It was the first game I’ve not watched in many years.
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - crashlander - 08-23-2024
(08-23-2024, 09:22 AM)DJC link Wrote:I didn’t vote for the Hawthorn game Crash. I had another commitment that prevented me from watching the game live and I just couldn’t bring myself to watch a replay. It was the first game I’ve not watched in many years.I don't blame you. I miss sometimes when we lose. I can't stand to watch the replay either.
And if ever there was a reason for not watching us, this round was it.
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - crashlander - 08-29-2024
AFL 2024 Rd 23: Carlton vs West Coast
Considering the players we had out and that we played over in Perth, this was a win for the ages. We so smashed the Weagles that they didn't even turn up the next week after having 3 wins on the trot.
Trends:
[1] There were 14 voters this round, which is more than double last week and nearly double the same round last year. Please do vote, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate. It makes our statistics more reliable. It is a part of the CSC experience.
[2] The rating was a 9.93, which is an A. This is the 3rd highest rating for the year.
[3] 15 players managed a mention this week. It is probably par for the course these days, but it is a huge improvement over last week.
[4] The average vote this week was 30, which is more than respectable.
[5] 5 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is more like it.
[6] Patrick Cripps stood out for top spot this week, managing 475 votes, the largest score of the season and really Judd-esque. Hewett was 2nd with 273 votes.
[7]Two[/b] player managed votes from everyone this week: Cripps and Kemp. Hewett and Pittonet missed from one voter.
[8] Our youngsters made a mark this week. Kemp got over 100 votes. Elijah and Ollie Hollands also were significant votes getters. Cowan got a couple as well, as did Corey Durdin.
[9] Votes were spread around all zones this week, although the mids did best. Our mids were dominant.
Votes:
Cripps, Patrick 475
Hewett, George 273
Kemp, Brodie 170
Pittonet, Marc 149
Weitering, Jacob 145
Hollands, Oliver 60
Hollands, Elijah 60
Kennedy, Matthew 53
Newman, Nicholas 46
Cincotta, Alex 25
Walsh, Sam 11
Cowan, Lachlan 7
Owies, Matthew 7
Acres, Blake 4
Durdin, Corey 4
Progressive Votes:
Patrick Cripps 5612
Sam Walsh 2649
Tom de Koning 2406
Jacob Weitering 1978
George Hewett 1795
Harry McKay 1738
Nic Newman 1621
Blake Acres 1391
Charlie Curnow 1290
Matthew Kennedy 1089
Adam Saad 814
Marc Pittonet 808
Elijah Hollands 801
Mitch McGovern 731
Brodie Kemp 574
Alex Cincotta 506
Zac Williams 360
Matthew Owies 352
Adam Cerra 296
Ollie Hollands 283
Jordan Boyd 228
Matthew Cottrell 203
Lachie Fogarty 199
Orazio Fantasia 116
Lachie Cowan 108
Jack Carroll 79
Lewis Young 73
Jesse Motlop 54
David Cuningham 13
Jack Martin 5
Corey Durdin 4
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - crashlander - 10-05-2024
AFL 2024 Rd 24: Carlton vs St. Kilda
Losing as we did was heart-breaking. A decent effort, considering the guys we had unavailable, but ...
Trends:
[1] There were 12 voters this round, which is2 less than last week's stunning win. Please do vote in 2025, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate. It makes our statistics more reliable. It is a part of the CSC experience.
[2] The rating was a 8.70, which is an B-. This is quite high for a loss, especially as we should have won.
[3] 13 players managed a mention this week.
[4] The average vote this week was 28, which is respectable.
[5] 5 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is something considering that we lost.
[6] Patrick Cripps stood out for top spot this week, managing 319 votes. Hewett was 2nd with 273 votes for the 2nd week in a row.
[7]One[/b] player managed votes from everyone this week: Patrick Cripps. Hewett and Newman missed from one voter, while Acres missed from 2.
[8] Our youngsters were not as prominent this round. Ollie Hollands was significant andd Cooper Lord managed his first votes on his 2nd outing.
[9] Votes were spread around all zones this week, although the mids did best.
Votes:
Cripps, Patrick 319
Newman, Nicholas 243
Hewett, George 207
Walsh, Sam 138
Acres, Blake 105
Pittonet, Marc 80
Weitering, Jacob 51
Hollands, Oliver 40
Saad, Adam 40
Cincotta, Alex 29
Fantasia, Orazio 25
Cooper Lord 14
Binns, Jaxon 11
Hollands, Elijah 4
Progressive Voting:
Patrick Cripps 5930
Sam Walsh 2787
Tom de Koning 2406
Jacob Weitering 2029
George Hewett 2002
Nic Newman 1864
Harry McKay 1738
Blake Acres 1496
Charlie Curnow 1290
Matthew Kennedy 1089
Marc Pittonet 888
Adam Saad 854
Elijah Hollands 805
Mitch McGovern 731
Brodie Kemp 574
Alex Cincotta 535
Zac Williams 360
Matthew Owies 352
Ollie Hollands 323
Adam Cerra 296
Jordan Boyd 228
Matt Cottrell 203
Lachie Fogarty 199
Orazio Fantasia 141
Lachie Cowan 108
Jack Carroll 79
Lewis Young 73
Jesse Motlop 54
Cooper Lord 15
David Cuningham 13
Jaxon Binns 11
Jack Martin 5
Corey Durdin 4
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - crashlander - 10-05-2024
AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane at the 'Gabba
What a disaster to finish the season.
Trends:
[1] There were 11 voters this time, which is more than reasopnable considering our 1st half. What a time to play opur worst half of footy for the year! Please do vote in 2025, win, lose or draw: it is something we appreciate. It makes our statistics more reliable. It is a part of the CSC experience.
[2] The rating was a 6.33, which is an E+. No major surprise, considering how bad we were for half a game, but it probably underestimates our effort after half time.
[3] 14 players managed a mention this week.
[4] The average vote this week was 22, which tells you most of what you need to know.
[5] 3 players managed 100 votes or more this week, which is something considering that we lost the way we did.
[6] George Hewett stood out for top spot this week, managing 242 votes. Cripps and de Koning got 2nd and 3rd respectively.
[7]Two[/b] player managed votes from everyone this week: Hewett and Young. Cripps, de Koning and Walsh missed from 1 voter.
[8] Our youngsters were not as prominent this round. Cowan, and the Hollands boys got some votes.
[9] Votes were spread around all zones this week, although the mids did best. We were ordinary in most areas for too long.
Votes:
Hewett, George 242
Cripps, Patrick 132
de Koning, Tom 101
Newman, Nicholas 92
Walsh, Sam 92
Young, Lewis 92
Weitering, Jacob 81
Acres, Blake 43
Cowan, Lachlan 35
Hollands, Oliver 14
Saad, Adam 9
McKay, Harrison 9
Docherty, Sam 6
Hollands, Elijah 3
Final Voting:
Patrick Cripps 6063
Sam Walsh 2879
Tom de Koning 2507
George Hewett 2244
Jacob Weitering 2109
Nic Newman 1956
Harry McKay 1746
Blake Acres 1539
Charlie Curnow 1290
Matthew Kennedy 1089
Marc Pittonet 888
Adam Saad 862
Elijah Hollands 808
Mitch McGovern 731
Brodie Kemp 574
Alex Cincotta 535
Zac Williams 360
Matt Owies 352
Ollie Hollands 337
Adam Cerra 296
Jordan Boyd 228
Matthew Cottrell 203
Lachie Fogarty 199
Lewis Young 165
Lachie Cowan 143
Orazio Fantasia 141
Jack Carroll 79
Jesse Motlop 54
Cooper Lord 15
David Cuningham 13
Jaxon Binns 11
Sam Docherty 6
Jack Martin 5
Corey Durdin 4
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - crashlander - 10-05-2024
Congratulations to Patrick Cripps on winning the Jim Park Award with a whopping 6063 votes! No surprise that he won the Brownlow after a season like that!
Congratulations to Sam Walsh and Tom de Koning for 2nd and 3rd places, respectively. Considering that both were hampered by serious injuries, that is a pretty good effort.
It also shows just how injury-hit we've been this year.
It also shows just how much Tom de Koning has improved this season!
Final Voting:
Patrick Cripps 6063
Sam Walsh 2879
Tom de Koning 2507
George Hewett 2244
Jacob Weitering 2109
Nic Newman 1956
Harry McKay 1746
Blake Acres 1539
Charlie Curnow 1290
Matthew Kennedy 1089
Marc Pittonet 888
Adam Saad 862
Elijah Hollands 808
Mitch McGovern 731
Brodie Kemp 574
Alex Cincotta 535
Zac Williams 360
Matt Owies 352
Ollie Hollands 337
Adam Cerra 296
Jordan Boyd 228
Matthew Cottrell 203
Lachie Fogarty 199
Lewis Young 165
Lachie Cowan 143
Orazio Fantasia 141
Jack Carroll 79
Jesse Motlop 54
Cooper Lord 15
David Cuningham 13
Jaxon Binns 11
Sam Docherty 6
Jack Martin 5
Corey Durdin 4
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - DJC - 10-05-2024
Love your work Crash!
Re: Jim Park Analysis 2024 - townsendcalling - 10-05-2024
By the length of the Flemington straight!!