+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Sam Walsh Mark of the Year (/thread-4955.html)
Re: Sam Walsh Mark of the Year - Lods - 10-20-2020
Every time we (Carlton supporters) give Cornes attention he gets his jollies.
It's what his Carlton baiting is all about.
He's just trolling for a reaction
If he was on the forum he'd have been banned a long time ago.
In terms of the mark, it's probably a question of personal preference.
I love the big high mark as much as anyone.
Walker was robbed.
Others prefer the courageous 'back with the pack" mark
I remember thinking at the time of Walsh's mark....that's the best I've seen by a Carlton player for some years (probably since the Walker one).
Re: Sam Walsh Mark of the Year - PaulP - 10-20-2020
I for one hope that Walsh doesn't make a habit of those types of marks. He got a little chop out from Liam Jones which impeded Dixon to a degree, but that wont happen all the time, and Dixon or similar types at top speed could really inflict a lot of damage.
Re: Sam Walsh Mark of the Year - capcom - 10-20-2020
(10-20-2020, 04:21 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:If we are being really super honest, as mightily courageous as it was (John Brown and Nick Riewoldt like), it wasn't mark of the year in the vein of Jeremy Howe, Shaun Smith, Andrew Walker (Mark of the Year that was robbed) etc. Kane is a knob but as he said, there were probably better high marks (ie spectacle). But lets not begrudge the kid, it was super.
I totally agree GTC ... he came in from the side someways and though it was without doubt a superb mark, it isn't an all time classic. Newnes goal? That was and is.
Re: Sam Walsh Mark of the Year - Gointocarlton - 10-20-2020
(10-20-2020, 04:57 AM)tonyo link Wrote:The thing that probably got him over the line was that the body heading in the other direction was Charlie Dixon, on a day when he was treating Liam Jones like a ragdoll.Fair points T
Re: Sam Walsh Mark of the Year - Gointocarlton - 10-20-2020
(10-20-2020, 05:34 AM)capcom link Wrote:I totally agree GTC ... he came in from the side someways and though it was without doubt a superb mark, it isn't an all time classic. Newnes goal? That was and is.And to her credit, Carro said exactly that as did Hutchy. Said Newnes should have got GOTY.
Re: Sam Walsh Mark of the Year - crashlander - 10-22-2020
(10-20-2020, 07:02 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:And to her credit, Carro said exactly that as did Hutchy. Said Newnes should have got GOTY.Probably.