+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Lily Of Laguna (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: Ladies Lounge (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-19.html)
+--- Thread: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? (/thread-3665.html)
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - Robblues - 03-17-2018
(03-15-2018, 09:57 AM)LordLucifer link Wrote:I will be upfront here and state that I have no interest whatsoever in the AFLW, the little bits of seen look no better than an U/15 boys game.Agree with this, no interest at all. Seems almost like a political ploy we will let all sexes play etc , but as a spectial lacks skill sets, the intensity definitely there , and much credit to the ladies playing , but hasn't created the interest, personal opinion only
Question is, will this version of the game really stand the test of time or will it be a short-lived idea ??
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - Thryleon - 03-17-2018
The test of a sport isn't how well it does when it's good, but how poorly it does when it isn't going so well.
The girls have had a crap season and my interest disappeared with it.
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - flyboy77 - 03-17-2018
Quote:the AFL have an exceptional record in this sort of thing.
They do, do they?
I'm listening....
What a crock. The AFL is an overly powerful body that has long outgrown it's usefulness....and indeed, it's raison d'etre.
I can list countless things they have got wrong over the years.
Let me know when you want me to start? :o
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - DJC - 03-18-2018
(03-16-2018, 10:38 AM)mateinone link Wrote:God posts like these are utterly ridiculous.
if you have a different opinion you sre short sighted, but the oracles can see it better.
Eveyone knows that the skills will improve, that doesn't mean they will (and doesn't mean they won't) ever get to a level where the brand is strong enough for a professional full time league or that enough people will pay good money to watch it.
Australian's have a lot of choices on what sports to spend their money on and only a few of them attract really big crowds. To support a 10 player (at a guess) netball roster requires a lot less cash than a full time football league.
I think most people will be happy for the women if it takes off, but it is far from sure that this this brand will be a brand that people maintain interest in and importantly people and organisations want to put enough money into so as to allow the women to turn professional.
The debate is a reasonable one for people to have on both sides and certainly isn't a foregone conclusion it will be successful.
No apostrophe in “Australians” MIO, but that’s neither here nor there
Of course the debate is reasonable, but there is the fact that it seems to be largely conducted by folk of the male persuasion.
It seems to me that the AFLW has really taken off with folk of the female persuasion, and particularly with females who haven’t previously followed AFL. As females represent more than 50% of the population, AFLW has the potential to become more popular than AFLM. Whether that happens is largely dependent on the AFL’s ability to understand the phenomenon and allow it to run its course.
I have missed more games than I watched this season but I enjoyed our game against Freo (for 3 quarters). It was hard, there was a bit of niggle, and there was more than a hint of how the women’s game could develop, if wise heads prevail. The marking clash that knocked the stuffing out of Tayla Harris and two Freo players was one of the classic footy moments.
I reckon there’s a bright future for the AFLW, provided the AFL doesn’t stuff it up.
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - cookie2 - 03-18-2018
Women's soccer is pretty good imo and seems to be getting more and more popular. Some of the players are of a very high standard eg Kerr, Vanna and the Aussies have had some success. I'm not a fan of it though as I don't really like soccer. If the AFL wants to emulate this it must try and improve the spectacle.
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - LP - 03-18-2018
Local arguments for or against women's football are the very same that were floated around in the UK on the start-up of the Women's FA. Now WFA is live on Free-to-Air most weekends as an afternoon option for the lead up to a FA broadcast. They have it on in pubs a clubs, under pay-per-view regimes so they are actually handing over cash to watch it!
I was in the UK recently and the WFA was attracting crowds of 15000 for typical games and it was OK to watch. In fact the lack of staging for frees, or badgering and begging to referees, made it a game that seemed to flow better than the men's game!
With the WFA the same obvious differences appear, the power in kicks and brute force, but I wouldn't say speed was a big difference, and the girls I watched were very agile and well coordinated, perhaps even better than the men at the finer subtle skills.
The men could learn a thing or two from the girls about team-work and structures, I suppose it's the old multi-tasking argument! :o
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - charlieK - 03-18-2018
(03-18-2018, 09:15 PM)LP link Wrote:Local arguments for or against women's football are the very same that were floated around in the UK on the start-up of the Women's FA. Now WFA is live on Free-to-Air most weekends as an afternoon option for the lead up to a FA broadcast. They have it on in pubs a clubs, under pay-per-view regimes so they are actually handing over cash to watch it!
I was in the UK recently and the WFA was attracting crowds of 15000 for typical games and it was OK to watch. In fact the lack of staging for frees, or badgering and begging to referees, made it a game that seemed to flow better than the men's game!
With the WFA the same obvious differences appear, the power in kicks and brute force, but I wouldn't say speed was a big difference, and the girls I watched were very agile and well coordinated, perhaps even better than the men at the finer subtle skills.
The men could learn a thing or two from the girls about team-work and structures, I suppose it's the old multi-tasking argument! :o
Its an awful brand. They cannot kick. Will be extinct in 5.
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - townsendcalling - 03-18-2018
(03-18-2018, 08:30 PM)cookie2 link Wrote:Women's soccer is pretty good imo and seems to be getting more and more popular. Some of the players are of a very high standard eg Kerr, Vanna and the Aussies have had some success. I'm not a fan of it though as I don't really like soccer. If the AFL wants to emulate this it must try and improve the spectacle.
Surely some of our top Matildas and international netballers must be scratching their heads at the exposure that this group of (mostly) suburban triers is receiving. Also, with the AFLX and the far stronger teams being fielded for the JLT, the AFL has taken a fair bit of oxygen away from AFLW.
Re: Womens Footy - Will It Really Last ?? - LP - 03-18-2018
(03-18-2018, 08:30 PM)cookie2 link Wrote:Women's soccer is pretty good imo and seems to be getting more and more popular. Some of the players are of a very high standard eg Kerr, Vanna and the Aussies have had some success. I'm not a fan of it though as I don't really like soccer. If the AFL wants to emulate this it must try and improve the spectacle.
Agreed, I think they(The AFL) made a mistake it trying to have the girls play to the same tactical game style as the men. Instead they should be developing game tactics that play to the girls strengths and weaknesses.