+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Our "AFL Final Four 22" (/thread-2549.html)
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - LP - 04-21-2016
Interesting reading this thread, how attitudes have changed in just a few games! :o
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - flyboy77 - 04-21-2016
(04-21-2016, 02:25 PM)Thryleon link Wrote:Considering all your TBA, I would have omitted Gibbs.
His super coach scores are the only thing good about his footy this year.
Gibbs is the prime example of why we are such an ordinary team.
We simply get next to nothing, on the whole, out of our ENTIRE senior group.....whether injured, disinterested or whatever.
1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Kreuzer
4. Walker
5. Thomas
6. Jamison
7. Everitt
8. Rowe - been serviceable in 2016 imo.
Three #1s draft picks, 2 #2 picks, etc.
Leaving 1AW out of the mix due to injury - the other 7 are actually producing less in 2016 (granted only 4 games in) than they did in 2015 - and that's saying something.
These are the guys that should be the engine of the team out there - think Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis (retired?), Burgoyne, Gibson, Roughy - you never, ever see these blokes go missing.....so why do ours repeatedly?
Focusing on Gibbs, even if he gets 30 disposals, we all know 25 of them are soft, on the outside, gets that have no real impact on the game.
Shame we can't trade players mid season.
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - JonHenry - 04-21-2016
(04-21-2016, 10:35 PM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Gibbs is the prime example of why we are such an ordinary team.
We simply get next to nothing, on the whole, out of our ENTIRE senior group.....whether injured, disinterested or whatever.
1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Kreuzer
4. Walker
5. Thomas
6. Jamison
7. Everitt
8. Rowe - been serviceable in 2016 imo.
Three #1s draft picks, 2 #2 picks, etc.
Leaving 1AW out of the mix due to injury - the other 7 are actually producing less in 2016 (granted only 4 games in) than they did in 2015 - and that's saying something.
These are the guys that should be the engine of the team out there - think Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis (retired?), Burgoyne, Gibson, Roughy - you never, ever see these blokes go missing.....so why do ours repeatedly?
Focusing on Gibbs, even if he gets 30 disposals, we all know 25 of them are soft, on the outside, gets that have no real impact on the game.
Shame we can't trade players mid season.
Many on here and at the club have over rated these guys for years.
If you are top 10 draft pick and not elite by 24, questions really should be asked.
And when I say elite, that means in more than one facet of the game. Clearance, Tackling, Speed, Leadership, Disposal, Goal Kicking, Defence.
Our guys are just way too happy to say they are AFL footballers, not successful AFL footballers.
Thanks for the great pay check.
It's such a shame we don't have incentivized payments via ladder position.
Imagine if Gibbs and Murphy earned 18% less for finishing last.
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - flyboy77 - 04-21-2016
I left Simmo out for obvious reasons - always tries his guts out even if his time is coming to an end.....
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - cookie2 - 04-21-2016
(04-21-2016, 10:35 PM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Gibbs is the prime example of why we are such an ordinary team.
We simply get next to nothing, on the whole, out of our ENTIRE senior group.....whether injured, disinterested or whatever.
1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Kreuzer
4. Walker
5. Thomas
6. Jamison
7. Everitt
8. Rowe - been serviceable in 2016 imo.
Three #1s draft picks, 2 #2 picks, etc.
Leaving 1AW out of the mix due to injury - the other 7 are actually producing less in 2016 (granted only 4 games in) than they did in 2015 - and that's saying something.
These are the guys that should be the engine of the team out there - think Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis (retired?), Burgoyne, Gibson, Roughy - you never, ever see these blokes go missing.....so why do ours repeatedly?
Focusing on Gibbs, even if he gets 30 disposals, we all know 25 of them are soft, on the outside, gets that have no real impact on the game.
Shame we can't trade players mid season.
Have no fear FB. The winds of change are now blowing strongly through our ranks and within the next year or two only those hungry for success and willing to work hard will remain.
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - Gointocarlton - 04-21-2016
(04-21-2016, 10:42 PM)JonHenry link Wrote:Many on here and at the club have over rated these guys for years.Not me
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - IvanAwfulbigone - 04-21-2016
(04-21-2016, 11:07 PM)cookie2 link Wrote:Have no fear FB. The winds of change are now blowing strongly through our ranks and within the next year or two only those hungry for success and willing to work hard will remain.
Chapters in the next Carlton FC history book - decade by decade...
1995-2004
Blues Become Most Successful Team Ever
2005-2014
The Wasted Years
2015-2024
The Long Road Back
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - laj - 04-22-2016
(04-21-2016, 10:35 PM)flyboy77 link Wrote:Gibbs is the prime example of why we are such an ordinary team.
We simply get next to nothing, on the whole, out of our ENTIRE senior group.....whether injured, disinterested or whatever.
1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Kreuzer
4. Walker
5. Thomas
6. Jamison
7. Everitt
8. Rowe - been serviceable in 2016 imo.
Three #1s draft picks, 2 #2 picks, etc.
Leaving 1AW out of the mix due to injury - the other 7 are actually producing less in 2016 (granted only 4 games in) than they did in 2015 - and that's saying something.
These are the guys that should be the engine of the team out there - think Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis (retired?), Burgoyne, Gibson, Roughy - you never, ever see these blokes go missing.....so why do ours repeatedly?
Focusing on Gibbs, even if he gets 30 disposals, we all know 25 of them are soft, on the outside, gets that have no real impact on the game.
Shame we can't trade players mid season.
I'll cut Murphy some slack because of an interrupted pre-season with his shoulder. Will do the same for Jammo as he's been a great servant but is obviously finished, a place all players get to eventually. Walker had a decent first game but hasn't played.
Now i've said that, I agree.
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - laj - 04-22-2016
(04-21-2016, 11:12 AM)TheSheik link Wrote:I think we can make a couple of adjustments to our team now :
B : Docherty, TBA, TBA
HB : TBA, Weitering, Plowman
C : TBA, Cripps, TBA
HF : Gibbs, TBA, TBA
F : TBA, TBA, TBA
R : TBA, Murphy, TBA
I/C : TBA, TBA, C. Curnow, TBA
I'm looking for Byrne, Sumner, Boekhorst & someone from the ruck division to put their hand up too !!
I hope that TBA guy is versatile. You have him filling alot of positions...lol!
Re: Our "AFL Final Four 22" - pinot - 04-23-2016
Im already depressed enough as it is with this team this is even more depressing...
Surely we will need to smartly trade some players in and throw some big dollars at key full forward. Jonathon Patton anyone?