+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane (/thread-6642.html)
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - DJC - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 10:39 AM)hanwell link Wrote:If Doc is fit to play, he has to start, so why not as a defensive forward on Zorko? Moir as sub?
Five years since I was last here, Bolton was coach, the Judge was Pres and was it Trigg as CEO????
Doesn’t time fly when you’re having fun!
It’s good to see one of the old regulars back in the fray. I hope your footy team goes well this weekend
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - laj - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 09:30 AM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:Cerra Gov and Martin are very risky given their soft tissue woes.Be very typical of us if correct. Half fit players with a name in the side ahead of younger blokes, who are performing and gave us some run that we lacked.
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - Gointocarlton - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 05:45 PM)laj link Wrote:Be very typical of us if correct. Half fit players with a name in the side ahead of younger blokes, who are performing and gave us some run that we lacked.How many young blokes with only a few games of experience do you bring into a cut throat final against the battle hardened Lions? We may think selections are risky but I am sure the team that's selected will be ready to go to give us the bestt chance of winning.
Just on finals experience, I saw a photo yesterday that showed we have the most number of players (29) with finals experience which I assume meant on our list. Next were
Swans 28
Lions 27
Port and GWS 26
WB 24
Geel 23
Haw 12
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - Gointocarlton - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 09:19 AM)rocky link Wrote:OK folks, so here is the VERY early oil I have on selection.No Charlie and No TDK is the word in the street so your mail could be spot on.
Ins : Cerra, Doc, McGovern, McKay and ..... Martin (as the sub)
Outs : Binns, Carroll, Lord, Moir & Owies.
Charlie couldn't get up nor could TDK and Williams
Disappointing that none of the young blokes get a run and somehow Motlop and Fantasia survive. Needless to say if we lose the MC will cop a fair bit of criticism and rightfully so.
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - Professer E - 09-03-2024
If half fit names play, break down or are simply crap, the torches and pitchfork stall might rock up to Royal parade.
Big no to Martin, and very leery about McG, Cerra and Williams.
Motlop and Fantasia need to do a lot better than 5 kicks and 1 tackle.
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - Baggers - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 09:19 AM)rocky link Wrote:OK folks, so here is the VERY early oil I have on selection.
Ins : Cerra, Doc, McGovern, McKay and ..... Martin (as the sub)
Outs : Binns, Carroll, Lord, Moir & Owies.
Charlie couldn't get up nor could TDK and Williams
Disappointing that none of the young blokes get a run and somehow Motlop and Fantasia survive. Needless to say if we lose the MC will cop a fair bit of criticism and rightfully so.
I bet even the MC doesn't know our final side as yet. Especially considering there's another training run tomorrow!
My real concern is all the marketing and attention given to the sentimentality of Doc's selection. A wonderful feel good and good news story, and no doubt will lift the lads, momentarily... but... how much of a distraction might it also be? Apologies for being a wet blanket, but there's a very real risk associated with a bloke who hasn't played in heat for so many months.
Hopefully the coaching group is more than aware of the risk of distraction and the risk of limited exposure to game day pressure and expectations for Doc. After five minutes on the field, it's no longer about the romance but about hard-nosed delivery of the job at hand; the harsh reality of the huge task ahead of Doc and the rest of us.
Brisvegas is the red hot favourite for this game, for good reasons. Reality. We're the deserved underdogs.
Selection will be a real balancing act. You can't risk taking too many injury prone blokes into a final. There are in form kids who've delivered over the past few games and deserve inclusion, and a number of blokes lacking match fitness who are susceptible to breaking down, regardless of reputation.
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - laj - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 08:48 PM)Gointocarlton link Wrote:How many young blokes with only a few games of experience do you bring into a cut throat final against the battle hardened Lions? We may think selections are risky but I am sure the team that's selected will be ready to go to give us the bestt chance of winning.The 3 that are performing...Lord, Binns with Moir sub. Always pick blokes who are fit and in form. Rule 101!
Just on finals experience, I saw a photo yesterday that showed we have the most number of players (29) with finals experience which I assume meant on our list. Next were
Swans 28
Lions 27
Port and GWS 26
WB 24
Geel 23
Haw 12
That has to be better than bringing in those that have missed huge chunks of the year and won't be near match ready for a final. Only way you win is with a fit side out there. Otherwise we get run over. Our slump started bringing in half fit, out of form players and killed our run.
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - ElwoodBlues1 - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 10:50 PM)laj link Wrote:The 3 that are performing...Lord, Binns with Moir sub. Always puck blokes who are fit and in form. Rule 101!People are forgetting you need match fit players and Brisbane are at full strength on their quick home deck.
That has to be better than bringing in those that have missed huge chunks of the year and won't be near match ready for a final. Only way you win is with a fit side out there. Otherwise we get run over. Our slump started bringing in half fit, out of form players and killed our run.
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - LP - 09-03-2024
(09-03-2024, 11:18 PM)ElwoodBlues1 date Wrote:People are forgetting you need match fit players and Brisbane are at full strength on their quick home deck.Agreed, we've been good for full games most of the season, even in the losses were we running over opponents late in many games, finishing stronger, we just lacked the polish to get the job done. Take away that finishing ability by only playing 3/4 and we move further away from success, especially in finals.
However specifically on Doc, I've no fear that he'll present himself in perfect 4-Qtr condition, the others I'm not so confident about.
Re: AFL Finals 2024 Carlton vs Brisbane in Brisbane - Professer E - 09-03-2024
Don't trust Martin and McG and Williams to front up fit. Saying you are and actually are are two different things. A quarter in and it's down into the room to get restrapped, extended stints on the bench ...