+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: New Skipper? (/thread-2467.html)
Re: New Skipper? - Gointocarlton - 02-03-2016
(02-03-2016, 06:02 AM)Wallsy link Wrote:I wouldn't be surprised if Gibbs gets the nod, as he is arguably our most important player right now all things considered, and he has been exceptional this off season apparently.No to Gibbs for mine, would be a step in the wrong direction if you ask me. Murphy was a bad choice at the time in my opinion but he has grown into the role and has improved over time. Reappoint him until Crippa and Weiters are ready (whenever that may be).
If Murphy is not captain this year, you have to start to think there is an ulterior motive, notwithstanding a Gibbs or other would be worthy. I am just thinking there's not much we can trade at the end of the year who is expendable but also valued by rival clubs. Don't get me wrong, I am not saying this is likely to happen, but the reality is even at 29 Murphy will command a decent pick in return and he won't be part of our next premiership assault. Gibbs is a year younger and has largely been injury free, so he could well be playing strong in 4-54 years whereas Murphy I am not sure has the body to last that long. But a team up the top would hand over a decent pick for Murphy IMO.
Re: New Skipper? - PaulP - 02-03-2016
Seems to me as though it's merely swapping like for like, and therefore a pointless exercise. Make them co-captains and be done with it.
Re: New Skipper? - DJC - 02-03-2016
I can't see Spornton's mail holding up but, if it does, it will polarise supporters even more than Murphy's appointment did.
Re: New Skipper? - ElwoodBlues1 - 02-03-2016
Gibbs as captain??......If I was Murphy I would be none too impressed and thinking about my future...elsewhere.....if it happens...
Re: New Skipper? - DJC - 02-03-2016
(02-03-2016, 09:22 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:Gibbs as captain??......If I was Murphy I would be none too impressed and thinking about my future...elsewhere.....if it happens...
Unless Murphy has decided that he doesn't want to be skipper - but that's unlikely.
Re: New Skipper? - Amers - 02-03-2016
(02-03-2016, 06:18 AM)SPORNTON link Wrote:Should be announced Monday morning.
I'd of thought the family day on Sunday would make more sense?!
Re: New Skipper? - cookie2 - 02-03-2016
I have difficulty imagining the captaincy being taken away from Murph against his will, especially if he is to be replaced by Gibbs. If it is going to happen then I would have thought that it is at his own request or with his agreement as part of an arrangement that he is included in. We'll see soon enough.
Re: New Skipper? - DJC - 02-03-2016
(02-03-2016, 10:36 AM)Amers link Wrote:I'd of thought the family day on Sunday would make more sense?!
No mention of Gibbs in the blurb
Quote:Everyone from Marc Murphy and Jacob Weitering, to Patrick Cripps and Kade Simpson will be there to sign autographs and take photos with the Carlton faithful.
Re: New Skipper? - Wallsy - 02-04-2016
(02-03-2016, 11:05 AM)cookie2 link Wrote:I have difficulty imagining the captaincy being taken away from Murph against his will, especially if he is to be replaced by Gibbs. If it is going to happen then I would have thought that it is at his own request or with his agreement as part of an arrangement that he is included in. We'll see soon enough.
Unless he is being forced out, which you would have to say would be cruel and unlikely.
But stranger things have happened.
I only say it is possible because Bolts has flagged that he is going to be very objective about this. Now that could mean everything or nothing. It could mean he genuinely wants all players inc the current skipper to show him their leadership creds; it could be he intends to re-appoint Murphy skipper but is just putting on a show to get all players to stand up and show their leadership wares; or it could be the club have conspired to push Murphy out (and even more remote is Murph has already agreed to this, perhaps even initiated the notion of leaving Carlton at the end of 2016).
I think the last option is most unlikely.
But as I said stranger things have happened, and Murph has copped some criticism from some people for his leadership, and we do not appear to have much trade collateral for the end of the year, certainly nothing that we'd be happy to part with and which would land us a first round pick.
The more I think about it, the more I think IF Harry and/or Charlie show some real growth quickly, we might consider trading Levi if a good pick is offered. Levi + our first pick for JOM anyone? Not saying I would do it, just throwing it out there.
Re: New Skipper? - cookie2 - 02-04-2016
@ Wallsy
Some interesting theories there Wallsy. Personally I think we could well expect something of the unexpected in that the club has stated that it is "in a hurry" and so may be tempted to try and pull a rabbit or two out of the hat.
Speculation will certainly run wild if Murph is not re-appointed and makes way for someone else, especially Gibba!