+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Pick your best 22. (/thread-5952.html)
Re: Pick your best 22. - pinot - 02-11-2023
Official Matthew Cottrell, Matthew Owies and Nic Newman fan club here.
Re: Pick your best 22. - Macca37 - 02-11-2023
I was struggling by the time I reached pick 15. Let's face it, we are selecting on last year's performances.
It's voting on a wing and a prayer with the new recruits. We don't know whether Marchbank or Cuningham will play again, and if they do, for how long. The same applies with Martin.
This vote would give a more meaningful result if taken after at least four or five rounds have been played.
Re: Pick your best 22. - DJC - 02-11-2023
(02-11-2023, 03:59 AM)Macca37 link Wrote:I was struggling by the time I reached pick 15. Let's face it, we are selecting on last year's performances.
It's voting on a wing and a prayer with the new recruits. We don't know whether Marchbank or Cuningham will play again, and if they do, for how long. The same applies with Martin.
This vote would give a more meaningful result if taken after at least four or five rounds have been played.
We can always do it again then ?
Re: Pick your best 22. - kruddler - 02-11-2023
(02-11-2023, 04:47 AM)DJC link Wrote:We can always do it again then ?We always do.
Re: Pick your best 22. - Lods - 02-11-2023
Yep
It's the poll that keeps on giving...
(....a chance to change your mind.)
I'm sure my best 22 will be different after Rnd 11-12 and again after the last round.
(...and again after the Grand Final
)
Re: Pick your best 22. - kruddler - 02-15-2023
OK, so based on 31 voters thus far, here is our 'best 22'.
FB - Docherty (31) - Weitering (31) - Marchbank (18)
HB - Martin (27) - Young (30) - Saad (30)
C - Walsh (31) - Cripps (31) - Acres (30)
HF - Kennedy (30) - C.Curnow (31) - Fisher (28)
FF - Silvagni (30) - McKay (31) - Motlop (25)
R - Pittonet (31) - Cerra (31) - Hewitt (31)
INT - McGovern (30) - DeKoning (28) - O'Brien (19) - C. Durdin (19)
EMG - Newman (17) - Owies (10) - Cottrell (10)
Next in line.....
Cuningham (5) - Kemp (3) - Plowman (3)
E. Curnow (2) - Boyd (2) - Dow (1)
Hollands (1) - Carroll (1) - Honey (1)
Re: Pick your best 22. - WASurfer - 02-15-2023
I know that 22 is based on the votes but if we were picking a team for Round 1, with everyone fit, I'm not sure Martin plays on a HBF. I'd have him in my best 22 but probably O'Brien out for Newman to play back. But looks like the concensus for best 22 was pretty much across the board?
Re: Pick your best 22. - Lods - 02-15-2023
You'd like that side to line up every week....but yep, it does point out a pretty glaring weakness
We lack a small/medium defending defender....although he may be found in that "next in line" group
Re: Pick your best 22. - WASurfer - 02-15-2023
Just read that Cincotta has been picked up in the SPP today.
Re: Pick your best 22. - madbluboy - 02-15-2023
I had Cottrell and Kemp in my 22 at the expense of Marchbank and O'Brien.