+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM (/thread-5778.html)
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - DJC - 08-25-2022
(08-22-2022, 07:49 AM)spf link Wrote:Depending who is fit (and mix), we may line-up something like:
FB Caleb Marchbank, Sam Durdin, Brodie Kemp
HB Jack Carroll, Mitch McGovern, Zac Williams
C Mitchell Moschetti, Will Hayes, Liam Stocker
HF Josh Honey, Ed Curnow, Tom North
FF Lachie Fogarty, Jesse Glass-Mccasker, Ben Crocker
FOL Marc Pittonet, Tyreece Lieu, Paddy Dow
IC Stefan Radavanovic, Alex Cincotta, Michael Lewis, Alex Mirkov
EMG David Cuningham, Joel Trudgeon, Domanic Akuei, Oliver Sanders
I don't think Ed or Cuners will be considered. Boyd was back in training but I doubt whether he'd be risked and I'm not sure whether Mirkov's gashed knee will be healed sufficiently.
Stocker won't play on the wing and will be in defence with Lieu and Plowman. Carroll will be on the wing and I think that Williams could spend time in the midfield. Trudgeon will be in the 23. I wouldn't be surprised to see McGovern in the forward line; we have heaps of defenders but not much in the way of forwards.
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - spf - 08-25-2022
(08-25-2022, 03:17 AM)DJC link Wrote:I don't think Ed or Cuners will be considered. Boyd was back in training but I doubt whether he'd be risked and I'm not sure whether Mirkov's gashed knee will be healed sufficiently.
Stocker won't play on the wing and will be in defence with Lieu and Plowman. Carroll will be on the wing and I think that Williams could spend time in the midfield. Trudgeon will be in the 23. I wouldn't be surprised to see McGovern in the forward line; we have heaps of defenders but not much in the way of forwards.
Thanks for the update DJC, I haven't been able to find a lot of up-to-date information. I now Cuningham and Ed Curnow were back running, but not sure past that. You would 'hope' that line-up could go deep into September.
I think Plowman played 12 or more games (like Jack Martin).
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - DJC - 08-26-2022
(08-25-2022, 12:15 PM)spf link Wrote:I think Plowman played 12 or more games (like Jack Martin).
Of course! Scratch Plowman from the list.
We still have plenty of good defenders, both AFL- and VFL-listed, but lack forward firepower.
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - LP - 08-26-2022
(08-25-2022, 12:15 PM)spf date Wrote:I think Plowman played 12 or more games (like Jack Martin).The qualification is 6 VFL games, Plowman only played 3!
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - DJC - 08-26-2022
(08-26-2022, 04:43 AM)LP link Wrote:The qualification is 6 VFL games, Plowman only played 3!
It's a little more complicated than that. If a player plays one or more AFL games after 1 July, they are ineligible unless they have played 6 VFL games. There are several other eligibility criteria.
Bottom line is that our team is:
Backs: Tyreece Leiu Sam Durdin Liam Stocker
Half-backs: Heath Ramshaw Stefan Radovanovic Alex Cincotta
Centreline: Tom North Will Setterfield Will Hayes
Half-forwards: Jack Carroll Jesse Glass-McCasker Ned Cahill
Forwards: Brodie Kemp Ben Crocker Jesse Motlop
Followers: Alex Mirkov Paddy Dow Joel Trudgeon
Interchange: Dom Akuei David Handley Michael Lewis Mitch Moschetti Zavier Maher
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - townsendcalling - 08-26-2022
(08-22-2022, 06:18 AM)spf link Wrote:CARLTON LISTED AND ELIGIBLE:
Paddy Dow
Brodie Kemp
Will Hayes
Jack Carroll
Sam Durdin
Liam Stocker
Alex Mirkov
Jessie Motlop (12 games)
Not as many big names as expected.
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - northernblue - 08-26-2022
(08-26-2022, 09:12 AM)DJC link Wrote:It's a little more complicated than that. If a player plays one or more AFL games after 1 July, they are ineligible unless they have played 6 VFL games. There are several other eligibility criteria.
Bottom line is that our team is:
Backs: Tyreece Leiu Sam Durdin Liam Stocker
Half-backs: Heath Ramshaw Stefan Radovanovic Alex Cincotta
Centreline: Tom North Will Setterfield Will Hayes
Half-forwards: Jack Carroll Jesse Glass-McCasker Ned Cahill
Forwards: Brodie Kemp Ben Crocker Jesse Motlop
Followers: Alex Mirkov Paddy Dow Joel Trudgeon
Interchange: Dom Akuei David Handley Michael Lewis Mitch Moschetti Zavier Maher
I’m glad to hear of the qualifications DJC, I’d rather something like that than a club that missed (like us) playing an afl squad against a VFL list.
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - spf - 08-26-2022
(08-26-2022, 09:14 AM)townsendcalling link Wrote:Not as many big names as expected.
Yes, I had believed it was 12 the cut-off, but there are more complex rules.
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - Baggers - 08-26-2022
(08-26-2022, 10:11 AM)northernblue link Wrote:I’m glad to hear of the qualifications DJC, I’d rather something like that than a club that missed (like us) playing an afl squad against a VFL list.
Yep, the system works.
Looking forward to tomorrow's game.
Re: VFL Finals Week 1 Sunday 28th August Collingwood v Carlton at Victoria park 1PM - blueianh - 08-28-2022
(08-22-2022, 06:18 AM)spf link Wrote:CARLTON LISTED AND ELIGIBLE:
Zac Williams
Mitch McGovern
Paddy Dow
Brodie Kemp
Will Hayes
Jack Carroll
Sam Durdin
Jordan Boyd (possibly inj)
Caleb Marchbank
Liam Stocker
Ed Curnow
Lachie Fogarty
Josh Honey
Marc Pittonet
David Cuningham
Alex Mirkov
Not sure about:
Jessie Motlop (12 games)
Jack Martin (12 games)
UPDATE WITH VFL PLAYERS INC.
Of the listed players, it looks like:
VFL (from last game)
Jesse Glass-Mccasker
Domanic Akuei
Tom North
Mitchell Moschetti
Stefan Radavanovic
Tyreece Leiu
Stefan Radavanovic
Heath Ramshaw
Alex Cincotta
Ben Crocker
Zavier Maher
Ned Cahill
Oliver Sanders
Joel Trudgeon
Like Stefan Radavanovic and wish we had 2 of him !