+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port (/thread-4163.html)
Pages:
1
2
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - ElwoodBlues1 - 03-02-2019
(03-02-2019, 02:14 AM)kruddler link Wrote:I'd be interesting in seeing your best 22 eb because I'm not sure you can count. Based on this post and some previous ones which include Williamson etc, you seem to have 30 players in your best 22.
Of all the names mentioned there all were in consideration for my team, but I could only fit half of them in. Jack, garlett, as well as Kennedy Williamson and obrien all couldn't make the cut.
Krud..My father was an accountant and taught me to count real fine..........what I think is our best 22 and who I think will play round 1 are two entirely different teams......eg players like Garlett, Daisy wouldnt be in my best 22....Kennedy and Obrien wouldnt be in either team, Williamson wont play round 1 but would be in my best 22 if he was fit and firing..
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - kruddler - 03-02-2019
I agree about the differing types of '22'.
That being said I'd still like to see your best 22.
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - LP - 03-02-2019
Did Owies play?
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - ElwoodBlues1 - 03-02-2019
Ok Krud since its still the offseason I'll play.....my best 22
B. Docherty Jones Marchbank
HB. Plowman Weitering Newman
C. Williamson Cripps Fisher
HF. SPS C. Curnow Setterfield
F. Gibbons McGovern Mckay
R. Kreuzer,
RR. Dow
Rover: Walsh
INT DeKoning, J, Silvagni, Cuningham, E. Curnow
Emergency, Kennedy, Obrien, Stocker.
Yep its goodbye to Daisy, Simmo and Marc Murphy.....Docherty and Williamson are in subject to being fit again.
DeKoning is the apprentice to Kreuzer whose tenure is limited due to age/injury...no use playing him in the twos, needs time now to learn from the best..
Stocker will enter the best 22 when ready and replace Ed Curnow but Ed is still ok and Stocker a way off yet.....
Obrien to replace Williamson or Docherty if they fail to recover properly......
Cripps set to play forward a bit more and rotate with Setterfield, Dow.
Wildcard player.......Pat Kerr......if luck with injuries went badly and we lost say McGovern or Weitering or Marchbank i think Kerr would get his opportunity
and could kick start his career. If that doesnt happen and he vegetates in the NB's he will probably get the chop....or rookied at best..
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - kruddler - 03-02-2019
I knew something didn't add up with your numbers, now I can see why. No daisy, simmo and Murphy? It's not 2021...yet.
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - Amers - 03-02-2019
(03-02-2019, 03:27 AM)LP link Wrote:Did Owies play?
No, nor did Cottrell.
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - Amers - 03-02-2019
(03-02-2019, 01:55 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:Amers...we cant play them all in the seniors and I dont see Kennedy replacing any of the present onball lineup.....Obrien probably has to sit and wait this season out and then Simpson and Daisy will retire
which should give him an opening back into the seniors.
Jack Silvagni, Gibbons, and Cuningham have all come from nowhere to lock in senior spots for rnd 1 and Garlett appears set for a defensive role down back........
I like Kennedy and think he is a honest handy footballer but Setterfield and Dow are ahead of him in that bigger mid role and I reckon he has to find another position like a half back flank to make him
a more versatile player.....injuries may help him get back in the team but I dont see him in our best 22 at this stage..
EB, your right, we can't fit them all in, there are some unlucky guys who are going to miss out..... it also means IMO anyway that we are going to have 1 heck of a VFL side this year, injuries pending of course!
Re: VFL Practice match Blues vs. Port - LP - 03-16-2019
Any news on Owies?