+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: VFL Practice Match: Northern Blues vs Werribee on Sunday at Arden Street (/thread-3296.html)
Pages:
1
2
Re: VFL Practice Match: Northern Blues vs Werribee on Sunday at Arden Street - ElwoodBlues1 - 05-29-2017
(05-28-2017, 10:43 PM)cimm1979 link Wrote:Did you watch it EB?
What did you think of Kody Manning?. plays as a medium forward for West Perth but played as a BP/HBF in the state game and looked pretty good in the half I watched. Hard at it. Think Dennis Armfield but with real footballing nous and skills. Bit slower than Dennis, but who isn't. Probably a bit old for us but better than quite a few of the numpties on lists at the moment.
Remember a bit of Manning, tackles well and does have that Armfield theme to his play but as you say is a bit more smooth than Denis...reckon he is more AFL ready than say Boekhorst who isnt physical enough...
Re: VFL Practice Match: Northern Blues vs Werribee on Sunday at Arden Street - cimm1979 - 05-29-2017
(05-29-2017, 01:50 AM)shadesy link Wrote:I called for Manning to be drafted 2 years ago.
You're a fair way in front of me then.
I only saw him as a bit of a highlights player but he had a few moments in the state game playing HBF where he looked very good. Had one bit were he smashed into the Vic player (in a pack) took the ball off him, ran off handballed to another WA player , ran past received the handball and delivered a lace out pass to the forward through traffic.
I haven't seen Boek (or bugger all players for that matter) do that kind of thing. It was the physical attack that won it but the polish after was terrific.
Re: VFL Practice Match: Northern Blues vs Werribee on Sunday at Arden Street - ElwoodBlues1 - 05-29-2017
(05-29-2017, 05:37 AM)cimm1979 link Wrote:You're a fair way in front of me then.
I only saw him as a bit of a highlights player but he had a few moments in the state game playing HBF where he looked very good. Had one bit were he smashed into the Vic player (in a pack) took the ball off him, ran off handballed to another WA player , ran past received the handball and delivered a lace out pass to the forward through traffic.
I haven't seen Boek (or bugger all players for that matter) do that kind of thing. It was the physical attack that won it but the polish after was terrific.
Surprised Freo or WC have not looked at him closer, not sure SOS would take an unproven 27(2018) year old player on but I think he could make a handy rookie for a club...
Ben Saunders at 26 would interest me...looks like he could handle the AFL and seems to be able to lead well and take strong marks one on one....Not true KP but more of that Jack Darling, Jake Stringer type of sized player who would play 3rd tall forward. Be a good player to have as a rookie while Kerr. McKay Jack and Ben Silvagni develop.....
Shane Nelson played well for the WAFL and has been unlucky not to be rookied over the years, probably too late now but I'd love to know why clubs have passed on him given the consistency he has showed....maybe his small frame is the only reason.
Re: VFL Practice Match: Northern Blues vs Werribee on Sunday at Arden Street - cimm1979 - 05-29-2017
(05-29-2017, 10:05 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:Surprised Freo or WC have not looked at him closer, not sure SOS would take an unproven 27(2018) year old player on but I think he could make a handy rookie for a club...
Ben Saunders at 26 would interest me...looks like he could handle the AFL and seems to be able to lead well and take strong marks one on one....Not true KP but more of that Jack Darling, Jake Stringer type of sized player who would play 3rd tall forward. Be a good player to have as a rookie while Kerr. McKay Jack and Ben Silvagni develop.....
Shane Nelson played well for the WAFL and has been unlucky not to be rookied over the years, probably too late now but I'd love to know why clubs have passed on him given the consistency he has showed....maybe his small frame is the only reason.
Definitely too old for us.
But he'd fill a spot on someone's list , even as a rookie, if they were light on in his position.
Nelson gets Mitchell type stats every week. I'd have him as having more AFL qualities than Kerridge but just lacks a bit of size .
Re: VFL Practice Match: Northern Blues vs Werribee on Sunday at Arden Street - Baggers - 05-30-2017
Just watched the VFL game highlights on the CFC website. Two things stood out from this minuscule sample... how often Le Bois figured in pressuring and linking and the bloody awful music backing.
