+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? (/thread-2688.html)
Pages:
1
2
Re: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? - shadesy - 04-28-2016
Murphy - Centre and Wing
Jones - FF until he stops trying
Gibbs - Third Defender/Sweeper
Smith - Forward Pocket when in form
Simpson - as Is
Armfield - High HF
Walker - As Above
Casboult - Romaing CHF
Buckley - Northern
Everitt - Northern Blues
Jaksch - Third Tall Forward.
Re: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? - jearnold - 04-28-2016
Added a few more based on my own frustrations...
Murphy - Mid
Jones - FF
Jaksch - FF - whoever is best of these 2 plays that role, the other NBs
Gibbs - Mid
Smith - NBs
Simpson - Half Back Flank
Armfield - Fwd Pocket - pressure
Daisy - Fwd Pocket - pressure
Galluci - Fwd Pocket - pressure - whoever the 2 best options of these 3
Walker - 3rd fwd
Casboult - Roaming CHF
Buckley/DVR - I would like to see one of these develop in time to a wing for pace, DVR preferred based on quality kick
Tuohy - Not a good defender, would like to see him on the other wing given his elite kicking
Everitt - Needs to watch tapes of Gunston, he should be able to play that same sweeping role but clearly doesnt
Re: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? - pinot - 04-28-2016
Murphy - rover/ HFF see Brent Harvey
Jones - Third tall forward
Gibbs - deep lying playmaker in between defence and attacking mids (murphy, kerridge, cripps)
Smith - not good enough
Simpson - running HBF/ wing
Armfield - Wing/ HFF
Walker - leading forward pocket
Casboult - target CHF
Buckley - HFF
Everitt - HFF/ Third tall
Jaksch - leading full forward see Gunstan
Re: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? - tonyo - 04-28-2016
Murphy - where he is right now - more rest in forward line to give us more star power down there
Jones - goalsquare lead up, give him 6 games in a row
Gibbs - a la Murphy
Smith - NB's but develop as a small forward
Simpson - in his best position now
Armfield - defensive forward
Walker - second option next to Jones
Casboult - half forward leading to centreline - and make sure there are 3 guys running past for the handball when he takes a mark
Buckley - being played out of position atm - his best work is when he can run in a straight line - back pocket/half back
Everitt - half forward - he is our best kick at goal atm
Jaksch - doesn't have the smarts to be a forward yet - get him ready to take over from Jamo - plenty of gun forwards learned their craft by starting as a defender.
The other guy I think we should consider developing as a big defender is Kreuzer - can't mark in packs, but spoils well and is a great competitor on the ground. He's not giving us too much as a ruckman atm.
Re: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? - BlueAvenger - 04-28-2016
(04-28-2016, 06:15 AM)shadesy link Wrote:Murphy - Centre and WingCouldn't agree more
Jones - FF until he stops trying
Gibbs - Third Defender/Sweeper
Smith - Forward Pocket when in form
Simpson - as Is
Armfield - High HF
Walker - As Above
Casboult - Romaing CHF
Buckley - Northern
Everitt - Northern Blues
Jaksch - Third Tall Forward.
Re: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? - ItsOurTime - 04-28-2016
Murphy - HFF/mid
Jones - NB
Gibbs - HFF/mid
Smith - NB
Simpson - HBF
Armfield - FP
Walker - FP
Casboult - High CHF
Buckley - BP
Everitt - NB
Jaksch - NB
(NB = Northern Blues)
Re: You're The Coach - Where Is Their Best Position ?? - maxm68 - 04-29-2016
Zach Tuohy....... fp hff midfield ?