+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast (/thread-2109.html)
Pages:
1
2
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - blue4life - 06-29-2015
5 Murphy
4 Kreuzer
3 Docherty
2 Wood
1 Tuohy
A very even performance, apologies to Bell, Simpson and a few others.
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - Slugger - 06-29-2015
5 murp
4 bell
3 Kruezer
2 doc
1 cripps
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - Vivian - 06-29-2015
Team b (down a notch for the missed shots)
Bell 3
wood 3
murphy 2
henderson 2
graham 1
docherty 1
armfield 1
cripps 1
Casboult 1
Bit stiff on Kruezer, Tuohy who also made solid contributions.
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - Navy Maven - 06-29-2015
Team C+ (bit sloppy and would have been beaten by better opposition)
5 Bell
4 Murphy
3 Casboult
2 Armfield
1 Docherty
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - sandsmere - 06-29-2015
Team. B
5. Murphy
3. Bell
3. Carrazzo
2. Docherty
2. Wood
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - OuterBlues - 06-29-2015
Team - B
5 - Murphy
4 - Bell
3 - Carrazzo
2 - Tuohy
1 - Wood
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - crashlander - 06-30-2015
Team: B+
I know I’ve rated this win below last week’s, but I think the opposition wasn’t quite as fierce this time around. Still, it was an excellent effort and one I am happy with. It is also the first time all year we have totally dominated the ruck.
Votes:
My usual caveat for a good win: these votes are severely deflated. Every single mention deserves about double what they are going to get. But 15 votes are all that is available.
[2.5] Bell
[2] Murphy
[1.5] Tuohy
[1.5] Kreuzer
[1.5] Wood
[1] Graham
[1] Docherty
[1] Cripps
[1] Armfield
[0.5] Curnow
[0.5] Buckley
[0.5] Carrazzo
[0.5] Everitt
Explanations:
[2.5] Bell: Tom had a great game, all except his kicking at goal. lLove his strength and attack on the ball.
[2] Murphy: Another excellent game.
[1.5] Tuohy: His best game for some time. He ran down field excellently and was really dangerous.
[1.5] Kreuzer: His best game in years. Dominated in the ruck and got possessions around the ground.
[1.5] Wood: Like Kreuzer, he really did well in the ruck and managed clearances as well.
[1] Graham: With Cripps being quieter this week, Graham stepped up and did a fine job.
[1] Docherty: Very solid in defence.
[1] Cripps: A solid tag with some questionable tactics, but Cripps still got it 20 times. Would have been even better if his kicking for goal was on target.
[1] Armfield: Dynamic!
[0.5] Curnow: Very solid in the midfield.
[0.5] Buckley: Kept his man quiet and provided some nice dash from defence.
[0.5] Carrazzo: Very solid in the middle.
[0.5] Everitt: Playing more consistently at the moment. Could have been much better if he had kicked straight.
Honourable Mentions:
Simpson: Had Simmo not kicked so poorly, he would have had votes. Unfortunately his disposal was way off the mark this week.
White: Very solid in defence, especially considering the difference in size between his and his opponents.
Yarran: Definitely vote worthy. How did he miss out?
Ellard: His best senior game for ages, because he spent time on the ball. He managed to do a good negative job and still get in the action.
Henderson: Worked very hard.
Casboult: Looked like having the game of his life for a while, but fell out of the game at times. His marking was excellent.
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - percy - 06-30-2015
Team B-
3: Bell
3: Docherty
2: Murphy
2: Kruezer
1: Carazzo
1: Wood
1: Tuohy
1: Graham
1: Armfield
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - Jofo - 06-30-2015
5 Bell
4 Murphy
3 Docherty
2 Carrazzo
1 Armfield
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Gold Coast - DJC - 07-01-2015
Team: B
5 - Murphy
4 - Bell
3 - Casboult
2 - Everitt
1 - Simpson