+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension (/thread-2602.html)
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - LP - 03-19-2016
(03-18-2016, 06:30 PM)Dave link Wrote:When we got him, the Collingwood physio team were sure he was finally about to get his body right again. I don't have many connections in the football world but I can speak with authority on this one. Collingwood obviously had their doubts but it wasn't because of his ankle
That is exactly what I have heard, they were not happy that after two years of hard work he looked like he would get back on the track at another club. Do your contacts know anything about an alleged Barney Rubble that occurred at the Lexus Center around that time. It's alleged a confrontation about Daisy's departure resulted in a locker door being ripped off it hinges and the contents of the locker being tossed out onto the bitumen at the rear entrance. Very mature behaviour!
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - Robblues - 03-19-2016
It would be very sad if the club had been negligent in there medical reports on Daisey , but there does seem to be something amiss here. Even last year his kicking was ok not distance wise , but in general
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - Dave - 03-19-2016
(03-19-2016, 02:17 AM)LP link Wrote:That is exactly what I have heard, they were not happy that after two years of hard work he looked like he would get back on the track at another club. Do your contacts know anything about an alleged Barney Rubble that occurred at the Lexus Center around that time. It's alleged a confrontation about Daisy's departure resulted in a locker door being ripped off it hinges and the contents of the locker being tossed out onto the bitumen at the rear entrance. Very mature behaviour!
Unfortunately not, I would have liked to see that!
I was only told of the disappointment of the medical team after they finally thought they were on track. I am sure the team is well and truly over their disappointed now though.
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - Dave - 03-19-2016
(03-19-2016, 02:11 AM)PassIt2Carrots link Wrote:Sorry, not doubting your contacts and the info above is in fact from Jofo claiming to have inside info as well. Hard to know what to believe but also hard to comprehend that he could be so broken and no one would realise.
No need to apologise, there is potential for both info to be accurate. In any case, if jofo's info is correct, then we deserve everything we get. You can't just dismiss your own med teams advice and still offer lucrative contracts.
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - Thryleon - 03-20-2016
Given its a medical team offering advice, it's possible that they didn't agree on the outcomes.
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - LP - 03-20-2016
(03-20-2016, 02:44 AM)Thryleon link Wrote:Given its a medical team offering advice, it's possible that they didn't agree on the outcomes.
Yes, and there are a lot of people who are non-committal and hand out vague assessments only to claim the high ground in hindsight, Doctors are not excluded.
But the real doubt is that we know the board was divided on Malthouse, split vote to get rid of Ratten, yet we would have to accept those who were unhappy did not leak the fact that Daisy was recruited against the club doctors medical advice. It's just very difficult to accept that was the case given our history of club leaks!
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - PassIt2Carrots - 03-20-2016
(03-20-2016, 04:41 AM)LP link Wrote:Yes, and there are a lot of people who are non-committal and hand out vague assessments only to claim the high ground in hindsight, Doctors are not excluded.
But the real doubt is that we know the board was divided on Malthouse, split vote to get rid of Ratten, yet we would have to accept those who were unhappy did not leak the fact that Daisy was recruited against the club doctors medical advice. It's just very difficult to accept that was the case given our history of club leaks!
Not if the bloke who was leaking the info was the bloke who got Daisy over.
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - LP - 03-20-2016
(03-20-2016, 04:49 AM)PassIt2Carrots link Wrote:Not if the bloke who was leaking the info was the bloke who got Daisy over.
The removal of Ratten was a split vote from the biggest board in the AFL, it wasn't a single voter and I'd assert not a single source of leaks.
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - PassIt2Carrots - 03-20-2016
(03-20-2016, 05:08 AM)LP link Wrote:The removal of Ratten was a split vote from the biggest board in the AFL, it wasn't a single voter and I'd assert not a single source of leaks.
You can't really draw any conclusion from that though.
Re: Daisy charged for striking Laidler! - can accept 1 game suspension - LP - 03-20-2016
(03-20-2016, 05:18 AM)PassIt2Carrots link Wrote:You can't really draw any conclusion from that though.
True, but our club does have that leaky history.