+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers (/thread-2130.html)
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - Baggers - 07-12-2015
I thought Wallsy nailed it.
I wouldn't hesitate to trade Hendo, Menzel and Yazz at year's end, that's Hendo the forward. Hendo the defender is well worth keeping and I bet that's exactly where the Cat's intend to play him.
Ye Rat O' the River is spot on re Menzel and Yazz.
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - Professer E - 07-12-2015
I'd drop Menzel and play Byrne or Jaksch as the third forward. He isn't working anywhere near hard enough.
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - cookie2 - 07-12-2015
The more I think about it, Menzel and Yazz do indeed need a spell in the NBs. Everitt gets another chance in the ones as he does more good things to compensate for his shortcomings, including kicking goals.
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - LP - 07-13-2015
(07-12-2015, 09:28 AM)PassIt2Carrots link Wrote:He had more clearances than any other player. Again. Without him we lose by more no doubt. Three of those frees were paid off the ball when he was tagging. More terrible umpiring.
That's not a correct conclusion, you're assuming his replacement would fair worse which is unfounded. They may have also got the most clearances with less turnovers and we win!
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - bancroft - 07-13-2015
I agree Yarram has his limitations, however as basically the only outside runner we have I am constantly amazed to see him isolated in the back pocket minding someone bigger and stronger, this is clearly not his go and he gets frustrated.
I can only surmise that they are trying to teach him a lesson on how to be a better backman or our defensive coach is being constantly outcoached.
He should never have been on Chapman nor minding Cotchin, he should have been up the ground providing run through the middle and passing to leading forwards.
I am slightly concerned that Barker now thinks he is a chance to get the gig and is thinking more about that than his original philosophy. We were back to numbers behind the ball bomb it long into the forward line and watch it rebound out.
Dropping Rowe, as it turned out was a massive mistake and whilst no-one could forsee the injury to Jamison it left us with few big forward or defence options.
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - PassIt2Carrots - 07-13-2015
(07-13-2015, 12:50 AM)LP link Wrote:That's not a correct conclusion, you're assuming his replacement would fair worse which is unfounded. They may have also got the most clearances with less turnovers and we win!
If his replacement could get 7 clearances they would be in the side already!
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - DJC - 07-13-2015
(07-13-2015, 12:52 AM)bancroft link Wrote:I agree Yarram has his limitations, however as basically the only outside runner we have I am constantly amazed to see him isolated in the back pocket minding someone bigger and stronger, this is clearly not his go and he gets frustrated.
I can only surmise that they are trying to teach him a lesson on how to be a better backman or our defensive coach is being constantly outcoached.
He should never have been on Chapman nor minding Cotchin, he should have been up the ground providing run through the middle and passing to leading forwards.
I am slightly concerned that Barker now thinks he is a chance to get the gig and is thinking more about that than his original philosophy. We were back to numbers behind the ball bomb it long into the forward line and watch it rebound out.
Dropping Rowe, as it turned out was a massive mistake and whilst no-one could forsee the injury to Jamison it left us with few big forward or defence options.
It was a massive mistake regardless of Jamison's injury - unless we're tanking :
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - Baggers - 07-13-2015
I didn't think that Rowe was dropped, rather out with an injury and the club decided to bring him back through the NBs... probably hair-splitting/a mute point.
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - MilkIt - 07-13-2015
(07-13-2015, 06:23 AM)Baggers link Wrote:I didn't think that Rowe was dropped, rather out with an injury and the club decided to bring him back through the NBs... probably hair-splitting/a mute point.
He was named as emergency against the Tigers.
Re: Round 15 Post Game Thread - Blues v Tigers - RiverRat - 07-13-2015
(07-13-2015, 12:52 AM)bancroft link Wrote:I agree Yarram has his limitations, however as basically the only outside runner we have I am constantly amazed to see him isolated in the back pocket minding someone bigger and stronger, this is clearly not his go and he gets frustrated.
Might be trying to get him matched up on someone other than a defensive forward because he just doesn't work hard enough to get off the leash when he is closely tagged.