+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Will Crippa win the rising star? (/thread-2283.html)
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - laj - 09-09-2015
(09-09-2015, 08:53 AM)kruddler link Wrote:Take some solace in the fact that the best judge of young talent gave Cripps 5 votes. Shifter Sheahan.
In order for Cripps to get 41 votes, he had to get 9 4s and 1 5. It's the only way its possible given that Hogan had 49, 9 5's and 1 5.
KB is full of crape
Two 5's, seven 4's and a 3? That's possible with that panel.
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - kruddler - 09-09-2015
(09-09-2015, 09:15 AM)laj link Wrote:Two 5's, seven 4's and a 3? That's possible with that panel.
That works, but how did Hogan get 49 votes from 10 people if Cripps got 2 5's? He can't, so Cripps couldn't have gotten 2 5's.
It's a mathematical logic problem.
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - laj - 09-09-2015
(09-09-2015, 09:25 AM)kruddler link Wrote:That works, but how did Hogan get 49 votes from 10 people if Cripps got 2 5's? He can't, so Cripps couldn't have gotten 2 5's.
It's a mathematical logic problem.
Good point!!!
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - Mantis - 09-09-2015
Hogan received 9 lots of 5 votes and 1 lot of 4. Total = 49 votes.
Cripps received 9 lots of 4 votes and 1 lot of 5. Total = 41 votes.
I heard on the radio today the next 2 players received 27 and 12 points with Brayshaw in 5th place with 5 points.
I still think Cripps performed in far more games than Hogan did. He also beat opponents far more experienced than him, and had more influence on the game far more often. Even when he was tagged.
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - Professer E - 09-09-2015
Looking at the highlights package Murph is sure going to enjoy being first receiver for the rest of his career.
Still can't believe 9 out of 10 "judges" put Hogan ahead but them's the breaks.
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - LP - 09-09-2015
(09-09-2015, 08:13 AM)laj link Wrote:Unless some wank only gave him 3 votes.
There are only 10 x 5 votes available, Hogan had to get 9 of them with a single 4 to make 49 points.
If KB gave Cripps 5 and Shifter Sheehan gave Cripps 5 that means Hogan can only have received 8 x 5 votes. Therefore Hogan could not score more than 48, 8 x 5 + 2 x 4 = 48 points.
Someone reporting the votes is lying if the reports are true, or the vote tally is bogus!
I heard Shifter's 5 vote reported on SEN directly after the 3pm shift change, I haven't heard Bartlett's claim.
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - laj - 09-09-2015
(09-09-2015, 11:10 AM)LP link Wrote:There are only 10 x 5 votes available, Hogan had to get 9 of them with a single 4 to make 49 points.
If KB gave Cripps 5 and Shifter Sheehan gave Cripps 5 that means Hogan can only have received 8 x 5 votes. Therefore Hogan could not score more than 48, 8 x 5 + 2 x 4 = 48 points.
Someone reporting the votes is lying if the reports are true, or the vote tally is bogus!
I heard Shifter's 5 vote reported on SEN directly after the 3pm shift change, I haven't heard Bartlett's claim.
Can't argue with that logic.
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - Lods - 09-09-2015
(09-09-2015, 11:10 AM)LP link Wrote:There are only 10 x 5 votes available, Hogan had to get 9 of them with a single 4 to make 49 points.
If KB gave Cripps 5 and Shifter Sheehan gave Cripps 5 that means Hogan can only have received 8 x 5 votes. Therefore Hogan could not score more than 48, 8 x 5 + 2 x 4 = 48 points.
Someone reporting the votes is lying if the reports are true, or the vote tally is bogus!
I heard Shifter's 5 vote reported on SEN directly after the 3pm shift change, I haven't heard Bartlett's claim.
But the question is.....
Did Bartlett say he voted for Cripps or just said he thought he'd win.
He wouldn't have divulged his vote before the announcement.
I doubt Bartlett voted for Cripps.
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - LP - 09-09-2015
(09-09-2015, 11:32 AM)Lods link Wrote:But the question is.....
Did Bartlett say he voted for Cripps or just said he thought he'd win.
He wouldn't have divulged his vote before the announcement.
I doubt Bartlett voted for Cripps.
I'd like to know where that Bartlett 5 vote claim comes from, if it was a grab of audio somewhere like the SEN reports on Shifter's vote. Tomorrow's KB show could be very interesting!
Possibilities for KB;
- He crapped on about thinking Cripps would win and voted for Hogan.
- He or someone crapped on about him actually having a vote!
- He actually did vote for Hogan and the report about Shifter's 5 is wrong.
- They both voted for Cripps and the crap is about to hit the fan!
Re: Will Crippa win the rising star? - laj - 09-09-2015
Everyone's votes