+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne (/thread-6213.html)
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - LP - 08-14-2023
(08-14-2023, 09:58 PM)tonyo date Wrote:I say we train all our backmen to wiggle all fingers when they are reaching to touch a ball on the goal line.You mean like the Filth players are all doing?
I thought they were just singing "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star" to the Daicos babies!
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - Blue Moon - 08-15-2023
Tell all the supporters of other teams and the media that the ball wasn't touched. It will wind them up no end. It is a bit like the Harmes incident. It doesn't matter whether the ball was in or out, we won the flag. It doesn't matter if the ball was touched or not, we won the game. We are Carlton, everyone one else can take care of themselves.
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - tonyo - 08-15-2023
(08-15-2023, 08:40 AM)Blue Moon date Wrote:Tell all the supporters of other teams and the media that the ball wasn't touched. It will wind them up no end. It is a bit like the Harmes incident. It doesn't matter whether the ball was in or out, we won the flag. It doesn't matter if the ball was touched or not, we won the game. We are Carlton, everyone one else can take care of themselves.Funny how this one gets all the press, and the two Jeremy Cameron ones have gone all quiet when they were much bigger clangers.
Cameron's mark in the third quarter was so far over the boundary, I'm surprised he wasn't asked to show his reserved seat ticket.
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - Gointocarlton - 08-15-2023
(08-15-2023, 09:43 AM)tonyo link Wrote:Funny how this one gets all the press, and the two Jeremy Cameron ones have gone all quiet when they were much bigger clangers.I thought this was pretty funny from Vic Pol
Cameron's mark in the third quarter was so far over the boundary, I'm surprised he wasn't asked to show his reserved seat ticket.
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - laj - 08-15-2023
(08-14-2023, 09:58 PM)tonyo link Wrote:I say we train all our backmen to wiggle all fingers when they are reaching to touch a ball on the goal line.
Richmond did that last year against us as we kicked for goal, sucked in the dopey dicks in the Arc, and cost us badly as it would have put us within a kick late in the game.
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - laj - 08-15-2023
(08-14-2023, 09:58 PM)tonyo link Wrote:Don't think you can draw this conclusion from this statement.
When looking at a touched call, there are two criteria (a) was it touched and (b) if it was, was it in the field of play, or behind the goal line. When the field umpire sends it upstairs, I am sure the expectation is that both criteria will be assessed. I think "Please make sure it was touched in the field" is a simplified way of the umpire requesting that both criteria are checked.
Our saving grace was the soft call from the goalie - if he says not touched, and video evidence can't prove otherwise, criteria (a) is out the window.
I say we train all our backmen to wiggle all fingers when they are reaching to touch a ball on the goal line.
What the goal umpire is saying is that he definitely touched and wanted to make sure it was in the field of play. As far as the ARC goes, as you said, they check both whether it was touched and if it was whether it was touched in the field of play.
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - LP - 08-15-2023
(08-15-2023, 11:55 AM)laj date Wrote:What the goal umpire is saying is that he definitely touched and wanted to make sure it was in the field of play. As far as the ARC goes, as you said, they check both whether it was touched and if it was whether it was touched in the field of play.Exactly correct, if he did not think it was touched he would have called a goal and asked to confirm that it wasn't touch or was touched over the line.
The truth of the situation doesn't suit those wanting to make it a debate.
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - Gointocarlton - 08-15-2023
(08-15-2023, 11:55 AM)laj link Wrote:What the goal umpire is saying is that he definitely touched and wanted to make sure it was in the field of play. As far as the ARC goes, as you said, they check both whether it was touched and if it was whether it was touched in the field of play.No problems, however Marchbank didn't have to come out afterwards and say that he thought it went through and was goal and that he might have cost Carlton the game etc. Just STFU mate and say nothing other than "I definitely touch it and the ump called it that way". Some of these players aren't the sharpest tools in the shed.
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - madbluboy - 08-15-2023
Did Marchbank really say that?
Re: AFL Rd 22 2023 Post Game Prognostications Carlton vs Melbourne - LP - 08-15-2023
I thought Marchbank comment was that he touched it but he thought it was perhaps over the line already, the question was never if he touched it but which side of the line it was touched on.