+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide (/thread-3353.html)
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - bigblue - 07-02-2017
(07-01-2017, 02:43 PM)townsendcalling link Wrote:5 pages and no word on Jack Silvagni. Is he a bit of a protected species?? Didn't see the game at all but others seem to be potted before Jack.
Maybe you should watch the game before making STUPID comments.
For a kid, he goes as hard as anyone. Chases, tackles harasses as good as anyone in our team.
As a fwd, struggles with the poor delivery to him.....as do all our other forwards.
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - Lods - 07-02-2017
I was worried before we drafted him that he might not turn out to be the player we hoped ,and the Silvagni name may have been ruling our hearts at the expense of our heads
I'm not worried anymore.
I've seen enough.
From memory he was a bottom aged draft pick...correct me if I'm wrong
Jack's still a kid.
A lightly framed kid who in the next couple of years will develop the needed strength.
Importantly he has a football brain and gives a 100% effort.
Surrounded by a couple more talented forwards in a year or two he will be a valuable part of this side.
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - LoveNavy - 07-02-2017
@ pinot
Inconsistent but still young - he will come good 22-23 years old. Needs to have a couple of A graders around him which he doesn't
Spot on. He's a young kid in a poor forward line.
Time is on his side and on our side 18/12 into a rebuild. Don't think his strongest critics could fault his effort and commitment to developing where/when/how to meet club requirements.
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - cookie2 - 07-02-2017
No concerns from me re. Jack at this stage. Has a maturity that belies his years and combines this with youthful exuberance. Is developing well and meeting all reasonable expectations IMO.
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - LoveNavy - 07-02-2017
One of Jack's strengths is his footy nous.
When his immature body catches up to his mature mind at AFL level, we'll have a clear indication of his worth. Both individually and as part of our team in the coming years.
My guess is that his steely determination to play for Carlton will enable optimal development. If that's good enough relative to his team mates, he'll be part of our next flag (OK, this part is my Carlton dreaming).
Mind matters in elite sport (any performance for that matter). That's where he'll have the edge on his peers. We all have many examples of when "he didn't have the right mindset".
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - LP - 07-02-2017
(07-02-2017, 04:58 AM)cookie2 link Wrote:No concerns from me re. Jack at this stage. Has a maturity that belies his years and combines this with youthful exuberance. Is developing well and meeting all reasonable expectations IMO.
He'll be a good player, but the current hype isn't matched by the performances. But that doesn't mean he won't be a 200 gamer.
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - cookie2 - 07-02-2017
(07-02-2017, 06:56 AM)LP link Wrote:He'll be a good player, but the current hype isn't matched by the performances. But that doesn't mean he won't be a 200 gamer.
I tend to let hype wash over me tbh, but I will admit to being on the Jones bandwagon atm! ☺
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - DJC - 07-02-2017
(07-02-2017, 03:29 AM)Lods link Wrote:I was worried before we drafted him that he might not turn out to be the player we hoped ,and the Silvagni name may have been ruling our hearts at the expense of our heads
I'm not worried anymore.
I've seen enough.
From memory he was a bottom aged draft pick...correct me if I'm wrong
Jack's still a kid.
A lightly framed kid who in the next couple of years will develop the needed strength.
Importantly he has a football brain and gives a 100% effort.
Surrounded by a couple more talented forwards in a year or two he will be a valuable part of this side.
I think that applies to most of our forwards
Jack is a footballer, not an athlete. While he lacks pace, he seems to have time to use the ball well. That was what impressed me about the first time I saw him in the NAB game against Essendon. I was also impressed with his willingness to "fly the flag" when a team mate was unfairly dealt with (same with Charlie Curnow). He will continue to improve as he builds strength and condition and further develops his footy smarts.
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - BluePhantom - 07-02-2017
How much does Marchbank look like SOS (senior ) when he wears the long sleeves. Some of his movements I need to do a double take.
Re: Rd 15: Post Game Passion: Carlton vs Adelaide - LP - 07-02-2017
(07-02-2017, 09:51 AM)BluePhantom link Wrote:How much does Marchbank look like SOS (senior ) when he wears the long sleeves. Some of his movements I need to do a double take.
Yes I've thought the very same, like a SOS / Christou hybrid!