+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal (/thread-3789.html)
Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - Lods - 05-13-2018
We may also have a problem with umpire contact...on two occasions. :
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - townsendcalling - 05-13-2018
(05-13-2018, 01:49 AM)Lods link Wrote:We may also have a problem with umpire contact...on two occasions. :
This is going to become really interesting. There needs to be ‘degrees’. Sicily, going out of his way to front the umpires and swear at them in what looked like an aggressive ‘out of control ‘ manner AFTER the siren, is far worse than Hawkins or Curnow. Also, vision from the NB vs Frankston game showed umpires twice place a hand on a player. Non aggressive of course, but are they the same rules???
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - Lods - 05-13-2018
(05-13-2018, 05:15 AM)townsendcalling link Wrote:This is going to become really interesting. There needs to be ‘degrees’. Sicily, going out of his way to front the umpires and swear at them in what looked like an aggressive ‘out of control ‘ manner AFTER the siren, is far worse than Hawkins or Curnow. Also, vision from the NB vs Frankston game showed umpires twice place a hand on a player. Non aggressive of course, but are they the same rules???
The problem for Ed is that it follows a week straight after the Hawkins incident.
They're likely to give him an extra week just because 'he didn't get the memo' not to touch them
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - ElwoodBlues1 - 05-13-2018
Ed is gone IMO, that was worse than Hawkins.......
Cripps will need to play a blinder for us to win IMO.......Oliver would be my Goddard this week...the kid really sooks when he is roughed up....
I give us a chance but Melbourne will obviously start favourites...I'd expect Kennedy to replace Ed....with maybe Jack a rough chance to play...
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - Thryleon - 05-13-2018
Any more than a fine will be an unfair outcome IMHO.
Ed didn't remonstrate and in no way was it worse than Hawkins who was staring at the umpire and was likely to have belted him had it not been for a GWS player pushing him away.
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - LP - 05-13-2018
(05-13-2018, 08:12 AM)ElwoodBlues1 link Wrote:Ed is gone IMO, that was worse than Hawkins.......
Even if it's the same as Hawkins, Ed will get far more because he plays for Carlton! :o
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - Lods - 05-13-2018
He'll get at least as much and probably a bit extra because after the publicity of last week you just would be so careful not to touch them.
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - Jack Burton - 05-13-2018
Has he been cited yet? I saw May from GCS has been
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - Lods - 05-13-2018
(05-13-2018, 12:34 PM)Jack Burton link Wrote:Has he been cited yet? I saw May from GCS has been
They've done May early because the Suns are going to China
Re: Blues Brothers trip to the tribunal - Jofo - 05-14-2018
The umpire was moving into Curnow's personal space. Curnow was moving away. It was a defensive action. Hawkins moved towards the umpire and was remonstrating. His was an act of aggression. THEREIN LIES THE DIFFERENCE. The media has made it all about touching the umpire which is too simplistic.