+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Lily Of Laguna (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: Ladies Lounge (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-19.html)
+--- Thread: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs (/thread-3145.html)
AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - crashlander - 03-03-2017
Sorry, I've been a little busy. I haven't posted the teams yet.
I will be going to this game with my daughter and the guys practice game as well. I am looking forward to it indeed.
SATURDAY, MARCH 4
Carlton v Bulldogs, Ikon Park, 11.35am AEDT
CARLTON
B: L.Attard 14, A.Downie 30, R.Privitelli 9
HB: L.Brazzale 12, D.Hardiman 31, M.Keryk 4
C: L.Arnell 13
HF: S.Hosking 10, A.Brown 27, G.Pound 6
F: J.Kennedy 23, B.Moody 16, D.Vescio 3
Foll: K.Shierlaw 25, K.Loynes 2 N.Exon 15
I/C: B.Jakobsson 35, K.Gillespie-Jones 5, T.Lucas-Rodd 18, T.Nestor 20, I.Ayre 22, S.Audley 26
Emergencies: B.Davey 1, K.Darby 8
No change
It would be nice if Davey was fit for this one, but I wouldn't put my money on it.
WESTERN BULLDOGS
B: L.Bailey 13, L.Moorecroft 23, K.Lamb 27
HB: H.Wildes 17, B.Hunt 21, K.Ebb 12
C: E.Kearney 5
HF: N.Callinan 10, L.Spark 11, H.Scott 22
F: J.Lambert 7, T.Ernst 19, K.McLeod 6
Foll: A.O'Connor 4, E.Blackburn 2, B.Lochland 1
I/C: L.Birch 18, M.McDonald 15, A.Gogos 36, L.Williams 9, K.Tyndall 8, R.Timmins 20
Emergencies: E.Gamble 14, C.Clarkson 24
In: A.O'Connor, R.Timmins
Out: E.Gamble, C.Clarkson
I am hoping for the sort of effort and planning I saw in the first 2 weeks.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - Jack Burton - 03-03-2017
Brianna Davey is a late inclusion, and very welcome too!!
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - LoveNavy - 03-04-2017
Great effort girls.
Young Bella Ayers having the time of her life. Keep it up.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - DJC - 03-04-2017
The crazy third man up rule strikes >
The boundary throw in clears the rucks and heads straight to a Carlton player who understandably goes for the ball. Free kick and goal to the Bulldogs.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - kruddler - 03-04-2017
(03-04-2017, 02:14 AM)DJC link Wrote:The crazy third man up rule strikes >
The boundary throw in clears the rucks and heads straight to a Carlton player who understandably goes for the ball. Free kick and goal to the Bulldogs.
Was pointed out by Mel Hickey that the umps told them if the boundary umpire effectively throws directly to another player, they are entitled to hit the ball.
Basically saying the umps got it 100% wrong.
Not sure you can blame the rule for that, more the umps.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - DJC - 03-04-2017
(03-04-2017, 02:42 AM)kruddler link Wrote:Was pointed out by Mel Hickey that the umps told them if the boundary umpire effectively throws directly to another player, they are entitled to hit the ball.
Basically saying the umps got it 100% wrong.
Not sure you can blame the rule for that, more the umps.
The ball wasn't thrown directly to our player, it simply cleared the two nominated rucks. We got a free kick shortly after when the ball cleared the rucks and landed on a Bulldog's chest. The umpires were consistent :
Nathan Burke's comment about allowing the ball to bounce before trying to take possession being contrary to the way the game has always been played summed it up for me.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - PaulP - 03-04-2017
Good effort by the girls to hold off a determined and fast finishing opposition. Nice to see the scores getting higher. Quite possibly we were saved by the bell, but there's nothing wrong with that.
Bravo bluettes.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - kruddler - 03-04-2017
(03-04-2017, 03:09 AM)DJC link Wrote:The ball wasn't thrown directly to our player, it simply cleared the two nominated rucks. We got a free kick shortly after when the ball cleared the rucks and landed on a Bulldog's chest. The umpires were consistent :
Nathan Burke's comment about allowing the ball to bounce before trying to take possession being contrary to the way the game has always been played summed it up for me.
The ball was thrown out of reach of the ruckmen. Our player was there. Thus it was thrown directly to our player. It was not a case of our player going to the contest and interfering with the contest.
Yes, it was evened up later in a similar situation.
Two wrongs don't make a right though.
As you mentioned, Burke and Hickey highlighted that the only alternative is for the players to run away from the ball as it is coming towards them. Clearly that is farcical, which highlights that the umpires interpretation of the rule was indeed incorrect as i stated earlier.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - laj - 03-04-2017
(03-04-2017, 03:09 AM)PaulP link Wrote:Good effort by the girls to hold off a determined and fast finishing opposition. Nice to see the scores getting higher. Quite possibly we were saved by the bell, but there's nothing wrong with that.
Bravo bluettes.
Must be close to a record score this year. Certainly a record aggregate.
Re: AFLW Round 5: Carlton vs Western Bulldogs - PaulP - 03-04-2017
(03-04-2017, 04:23 AM)laj link Wrote:Must be close to a record score this year. Certainly a record aggregate.
Could be Jim.