+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs (/thread-2120.html)
Pages:
1
2
Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - crashlander - 07-05-2015
I had a shocking night last night.
[1] NB's got thrashed by 100 points, which I discovered when I got to the ground.
[2] Carlton got beaten because we couldn't kick straight and the umps wouldn't know a free kick if they got one in the backside.
[3] I missed the train: it left as I was on the platform trying to get their attention. I got home at 1:45 and wasn't happy.
So, I was actually hoping someone else would start up this thread this week.
Well, probably too many people were as irritated with the game as I was, so nobody thought of it. Doesn't matter. Here it is. Poor out your feelings. This round last year we had a record smallest number of voters and none of them was happy. We'll see how many want to vote this time around.
Remember:
[1] At least 3 players need to get a mention.
[2] No more than 10 votes for any one player.
[3] Give a rating of team performance. It can be anywhere from A+ to F.
[4] Votes must add up to 15.
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - blue4life - 07-05-2015
5 Tuohy
4 Jamison
3 Buckley
2 Graham
1 Armfield
Team C
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - crashlander - 07-05-2015
Team: C
Bad kicking is bad football and we kicked very poorly. Especially for goal.
I thought the umpiring was incredible. I don’t think I have ever seen such a performance. We had 5 frees for the night in general play and 3 on the fulls. I find that illogical.
Votes:
[2.5] Tuohy
[2] Murphy
[1.5] Armfield
[1.5] Jamison
[1.5] Bell
[1.5] Buckley
[1] Graham
[1] Curnow
[1] Simpson
[0.5] Cripps
[0.5] White
[0.5] Everitt
Explanations:
[2.5] Tuohy: Brilliant for most of the night. Took marks in defence and kicked much better than most. A really good game.
[2] Murphy: Not as good as last week, but probably our most effective midfielder.
[1.5] Armfield: Armfield played one of his best games. He took marks that he hasn’t tried to for years. If he had kicked straight he would have won us the game.
[1.5] Jamison: Destroyed the Dogs forwards.
[1.5] Bell: Solid game with some nice bursts through the packs.
[1.5] Buckley: Excellent inn defence with his run and carry. His defensive work was much improved and his goal was one of the best of the year.
[1] Graham: Stepping up nicely.
[1] Curnow: Good at getting it and making it harder for his opponents to get it.
[1] Simpson: Except for his kicking, which was much below par, his game was excellent.
[0.5] Cripps: Deserved more votes, but his output went down when he was injured.
[0.5] White: Very good in defence.
[0.5] Everitt: When he went off our forward line stopped functioning. He took a couple of great marks and was really showing the Dogs that they made a mistake.
Honourable Mentions:
Yarran: Almost vote worthy.
Kreuzer: Brilliant early, but was well beaten after half time. Ran out of gas and couldn’t find the ball in the air.
Wood: Tried his guts out and took some great marks. However, his influence waned to almost nothing after half time.
Henderson: Worked hard.
Other Comments:
[1] Umpiring: We really need to complain about this. This was just so bad that English doesn’t have a word to describe it adequately. Poorer than the Greek Economy.
[2] I also find it incredible that Stringer was named in their best players with 10 possessions. The 3 goals hurt, but otherwise he was thrashed. He got half of his possessions in the period he was in the middle of the ground and provided zero as a forward, but for a 5 minute burst. His various opponents
[3] Kicking for goal: that was just so bad.
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - Amers - 07-05-2015
Team; C+
5 - Touhy
4 - Murphy
3 - Cripps,
2 - Graham
1 - Holman
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - Juddkreuzer - 07-05-2015
Team C
5 Tuohy
3 Murphy
2 Jamison
2 Cripps
1 Buckley
1 Armfield
1 Graham
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - ElwoodBlues1 - 07-05-2015
Team E
5: Touhy
4: Armfield
2: Cripps
1: Buckley
1: Murphy
1: Graham
1: Jamison
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - Baggers - 07-05-2015
Team C-
4 - Tuohy
3 - Jamison
2 - Armfield
2 - Buckley
1 - Cripps
1 - Graham
1 - Murphy
1 - White
Apologies to Everitt and Simpson.
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - PassIt2Carrots - 07-05-2015
5 - Tuohy
4 - Murphy
3 - Graham
2 - Buckley
1 - Armfield
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - DJC - 07-05-2015
Team: D
5 - Tuohy
4 - Murphy
3 - Graham
2 - Bell
1 - Armfield
Re: Jim Park Voting: Round 14: Carlton vs. Western Bulldogs - Blue Moon - 07-05-2015
Team - C
Touhy - 5
Graham - 4
Armfield - 3
Murphy - 2
Jamieson - 1