+- Carlton Supporters Club (http://new.carltonsc.com)
+-- Forum: Princes Park (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Robert Heatley Stand (http://new.carltonsc.com/forum-14.html)
+--- Thread: You've been ROBBO'd (/thread-155.html)
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - LP - 05-04-2015
In keeping with Shadesy's terrific early post match pre-game summary from Perth, sorry but I'm going early on this one!
[img width=350]http://resources1.news.com.au/images/2014/11/25/1227134/570297-7c01bc4a-745d-11e4-9e51-02293300d0bf.jpg[/img]
You just know it's going to happen!
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - PassIt2Carrots - 05-04-2015
Which begs the question, should a bloke that's not a leader be making leadership decisions at the club?
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - Thryleon - 05-04-2015
If you think one person ousted Robbo I reckon you might just have lost it.
Robbo is gone because of Robbo.
Not anyone else's reaction.
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - PassIt2Carrots - 05-04-2015
Leadership group wanted him gone. Murphy is the captain. He publicly endorsed the decision. How hard is it to comprehend? It seems your selective memory is in full swing again.
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - LP - 05-04-2015
Irrespective of the reasons, I doubt Robbo is a deep thinker!
It might be a race to see who gets in first, Robbo or Bell!
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - Thryleon - 05-05-2015
(05-04-2015, 08:53 PM)PassIt2Carrots link Wrote:Leadership group wanted him gone. Murphy is the captain. He publicly endorsed the decision. How hard is it to comprehend? It seems your selective memory is in full swing again.
Sure, Im with you that the leadership group endorsed the decision, and whether or not private or public, the reason he is gone, is because of the actions or inaction he took on that fateful night out.
Robinson is 100% responsible for WHY he is not there.
Responsibility lies with Robinson.
Murphy and the leadership group will own the decision. It was something that they chose to do in order to achieve a specific team goal that we would not be privy to. A difficult decision I might add and one I don't necessarily agree with either, but my opinion isnt important here, and neither is that of any of our fans, given our club ticked it off, the team ticked it off, and they are the ones who have all the information required to make a tough call.
We need to accept it and move on. Hell, its possible that members of our playing group are likewise split about this decision, and hence why we see so much disunity at the club, and even so, I still blame Robinson for his actions, and not the decision to move him on. We talk about holding people accountable for their actions, but we are not the first team to decide about removing certain charachters from their team for the greater good, its just that it doesnt seem to have helped us a great deal at the moment, which is why its annoying.
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - Baggers - 05-05-2015
(05-04-2015, 09:51 PM)LP link Wrote:Irrespective of the reasons, I doubt Robbo is a deep thinker!
It might be a race to see who gets in first, Robbo or Bell!
Or who's first to understand the question!
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - PassIt2Carrots - 05-05-2015
@Thry
Refer to my original post, the question is, considering Marc Murphy isn't leadership material, should he be influencing decisions at the club?
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - Baggers - 05-05-2015
Wo, wo, wo... Murph may not be Skipper material (though is growing into the role) but to suggest he is a poor leader is unfair and going too far.
Re: You've been ROBBO'd - Thryleon - 05-05-2015
(05-05-2015, 12:32 AM)PassIt2Carrots link Wrote:@Thry
Refer to my original post, the question is, considering Marc Murphy isn't leadership material, should he be influencing decisions at the club?
One of these days the club will learn that we have appointed a person into a role, and that person will do the role to the best of their ability, and not allowing them to do it will simply result in setting people up to fail, rather than succeeding under their own steam or failing on the back of whatever poor decision they make.
We also prevent Murphy from learning from an error he may have made, and therefore stunt his developement as a leader.
Making mistakes in order to learn a lesson is okay. Repeatedly making the same mistakes and failing to learn your lesson is not.
Our club is guilty of this, and I fear is doomed to continue making mistakes until it learns that replacing people is not the only way to improve.